arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2407.21209cs.HCecon.GNq-fin.EC
收藏

算法辅助决策与住房中的种族差异:对阿勒格尼住房评估工具的研究

Algorithm-Assisted Decision Making and Racial Disparities in Housing: A Study of the Allegheny Housing Assessment Tool

Lingwei Cheng, Cameron Drayton, Alexandra Chouldechova, Rhema Vaithianathan

AI总结:

本文通过分析阿勒格尼住房评估工具(AHA)替代VI-SPDAT后的数据,发现算法辅助决策虽使服务与风险评分更一致,但未能减少住房分配中的种族差异,并指出差异持续源于Alt-AHA工具及资格相关因素。

摘要:

美国各地对住房援助的需求远远超过供给,这使得住房提供者承担起对客户进行优先排序以分配这一有限资源的任务。为了获得联邦资金的资格,地方无家可归者系统被要求在其优先排序过程中实施评估工具。脆弱性指数服务优先排序决策辅助工具(VI-SPDAT)是全国最常用的评估工具。近期研究批评VI-SPDAT表现出种族偏见,这可能导致住房提供中出现不应有的种族差异。为回应这些批评,一些辖区开发了替代工具,例如阿勒格尼住房评估(AHA),该工具使用算法来评估客户的风险水平。利用其部署数据,我们进行了描述性和定量分析,以评估用AHA取代VI-SPDAT是否会影响住房分配中的种族差异。我们发现,VI-SPDAT倾向于给白人客户分配较高的风险评分,给黑人客户分配较低的风险评分,并且在AHA部署之前,白人客户获得服务的比例更高。虽然部署后的服务决策与AHA评分更加一致,并且AHA评分在不同种族群体之间的分布相似,但我们没有发现服务率差异相应缩小的证据。我们将持续存在的差异归因于Alt-AHA的使用(Alt-AHA是一种在数据质量较低的情况下使用的基于调查的工具),以及资格相关因素中的群体差异,例如长期无家可归和退伍军人身份。我们讨论了这些发现对寻求减少服务提供中种族差异的住房服务系统的启示。

英文摘要:

The demand for housing assistance across the United States far exceeds the supply, leaving housing providers the task of prioritizing clients for receipt of this limited resource. To be eligible for federal funding, local homelessness systems are required to implement assessment tools as part of their prioritization processes. The Vulnerability Index Service Prioritization Decision Assistance Tool (VI-SPDAT) is the most commonly used assessment tool nationwide. Recent studies have criticized the VI-SPDAT as exhibiting racial bias, which may lead to unwarranted racial disparities in housing provision. In response to these criticisms, some jurisdictions have developed alternative tools, such as the Allegheny Housing Assessment (AHA), which uses algorithms to assess clients' risk levels. Drawing on data from its deployment, we conduct descriptive and quantitative analyses to evaluate whether replacing the VI-SPDAT with the AHA affects racial disparities in housing allocation. We find that the VI-SPDAT tended to assign higher risk scores to white clients and lower risk scores to Black clients, and that white clients were served at a higher rates pre-AHA deployment. While post-deployment service decisions became better aligned with the AHA score, and the distribution of AHA scores is similar across racial groups, we do not find evidence of a corresponding decrease in disparities in service rates. We attribute the persistent disparity to the use of Alt-AHA, a survey-based tool that is used in cases of low data quality, as well as group differences in eligibility-related factors, such as chronic homelessness and veteran status. We discuss the implications for housing service systems seeking to reduce racial disparities in their service delivery.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑