arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2203.09859cs.HC
收藏

促进通信分析中的道德意识:调查智能应用中视觉分析的潜力和局限性

Promoting Ethical Awareness in Communication Analysis: Investigating Potentials and Limits of Visual Analytics for Intelligence Applications

Maximilian T. Fischer, Simon David Hirsbrunner, Wolfgang Jentner, Matthias Miller, Daniel A. Keim, Paula Helm

摘要:

近年来,用于分析人类通信数据的数字系统已经变得流行。在调查性新闻、犯罪情报和法律中,对通信数据的情报分析提出了特别有趣的案例,因为它们必须考虑到基本操作和数据的高度敏感性。与此同时,这些领域越来越自动化,复杂的方法系统可能特别相关,特别是在大数据方面。然而,通过转移责任,这也带来了危险。除了隐私问题外,这些危险还与不确定或较差的数据质量有关,导致歧视和潜在的误导性见解。可视化分析将机器学习方法与交互式可视化界面相结合,以实现人类的感知和决策。这种技术可能是设计和操作考虑这些道德挑战的有意义的交互式通信分析系统的关键。在这项跨学科的工作中,计算机科学家,伦理学家和科学与技术研究学者的共同努力,我们调查和评估使用可视化分析方法进行通信分析的机会和风险,特别是在智能应用中。首先,我们介绍了通信分析中使用的常见技术系统,进一步讨论了特定领域的伦理影响,紧张局势和风险。然后,我们提出了定制的可视化分析方法如何减少和缓解所描述的问题,无论是理论上还是通过实际例子。我们表明,为道德问题找到可视化分析设计解决方案不仅仅是一个优化任务,而是平衡和谈判这些权衡,正如我们所认为的,从一开始就成为系统设计过程的一个组成部分。

英文摘要:

Digital systems for analyzing human communication data have become prevalent in recent years. Intelligence analysis of communications data in investigative journalism, criminal intelligence, and law present particularly interesting cases, as they must take into account the often highly sensitive properties of the underlying operations and data. At the same time, these are areas where increasingly automated, sophisticated approaches systems can be particularly relevant, especially in terms of Big Data manageability. However, by the shifting of responsibilities, this also poses dangers. In addition to privacy concerns, these dangers relate to uncertain or poor data quality, leading to discrimination and potentially misleading insights. Visual analytics combines machine learning methods with interactive visual interfaces to enable human sense- and decision-making. This technique can be key for designing and operating meaningful interactive communication analysis systems that consider these ethical challenges. In this interdisciplinary work, a joint endeavor of computer scientists, ethicists, and scholars in Science & Technology Studies, we investigate and evaluate opportunities and risks involved in using Visual analytics approaches for communication analysis in intelligence applications in particular. We introduce, at first, the common technological systems used in communication analysis, further discussing the domain-specific ethical implications, tensions, and risks involved. We then make the case of how tailored Visual Analytics approaches may reduce and mitigate the described problems, both theoretically and through practical examples. We show that finding Visual Analytics design solutions for ethical issues is not a mere optimization task, but balancing out and negotiating these trade-offs has, as we argue, to be an integral aspect of the system design process from the outset.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑