印度平权行动政策的合宪实施
Constitutional Implementation of Affirmative Action Policies in India
AI总结:
针对印度异质职位预留政策缺乏合宪实施机制的问题,本文将 Saurav Yadav(2020)判决要求形式化为公理,并证明 2SMH-DA 是唯一满足要求的机制。
摘要:
印度拥有一项全面的平权行动项目,为各类弱势群体在政府机构中预留一定比例的职位。虽然在所有职位完全相同时,存在一种得到最高法院认可的机制来实施这些预留政策,但当职位具有异质性时,法院一直不愿认可明确的机制。这一空白导致违宪机制被广泛采用、诉讼不计其数以及法院裁决前后不一。我们将具有里程碑意义的最高法院判决 Saurav Yadav(2020)中的强制性要求表述为技术公理,并证明 2SMH-DA 机制是唯一适合克服这些挑战的机制。
英文摘要:
India is home to a comprehensive affirmative action program that reserves a fraction of positions at governmental institutions for various disadvantaged groups. While there is a Supreme Court-endorsed mechanism to implement these reservation policies when all positions are identical, courts have refrained from endorsing explicit mechanisms when positions are heterogeneous. This lacunae has resulted in widespread adoption of unconstitutional mechanisms, countless lawsuits, and inconsistent court rulings. Formulating mandates in the landmark Supreme Court judgment Saurav Yadav (2020) as technical axioms, we show that the 2SMH-DA mechanism is uniquely suited to overcome these challenges.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。