arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2202.00799cs.CYcs.HC
收藏

移除、减少、告知:人们希望社交媒体平台对潜在误导性内容采取什么行动?

Remove, Reduce, Inform: What Actions do People Want Social Media Platforms to Take on Potentially Misleading Content?

Shubham Atreja, Libby Hemphill, Paul Resnick

AI总结:

本研究通过368篇新闻文章的评估,探究了普通人对社交媒体平台处理潜在误导性内容(添加标签、减少分发、移除)的偏好,发现行动偏好存在明确等级且受党派来源影响,并指出误导性和危害判断可作为决定多数人认可行动的有效代理。

摘要:

为了减少虚假信息的传播,社交媒体平台可能会对违规内容采取执行措施,例如添加信息警告标签、减少分发或完全移除内容。然而,它们的行动和不作为都备受争议,并饱受党派偏见的指控。当涉及具体内容时,关于普通人希望平台做什么,人们所知惊人地少。我们提供了实证证据,关于一个政治平衡的普通评估者小组对368篇新闻文章的三种潜在平台行动的偏好。我们的结果证实,在许多文章上,对于采取何种行动缺乏共识。我们发现,行动的感知严重程度存在明确的等级关系,大多数评估者希望在最多的文章上添加信息标签,而最少采用移除。就多少文章值得平台采取行动而言,没有党派差异,但保守派确实更倾向于对来自自由派来源的内容采取更多行动,反之亦然。我们还发现,关于误导性和危害这两个整体属性的判断,可以作为有效的代理指标,用于确定哪些行动会被大多数评估者批准。

英文摘要:

To reduce the spread of misinformation, social media platforms may take enforcement actions against offending content, such as adding informational warning labels, reducing distribution, or removing content entirely. However, both their actions and their inactions have been controversial and plagued by allegations of partisan bias. When it comes to specific content items, surprisingly little is known about what ordinary people want the platforms to do. We provide empirical evidence about a politically balanced panel of lay raters' preferences for three potential platform actions on 368 news articles. Our results confirm that on many articles there is a lack of consensus on which actions to take. We find a clear hierarchy of perceived severity of actions with a majority of raters wanting informational labels on the most articles and removal on the fewest. There was no partisan difference in terms of how many articles deserve platform actions but conservatives did prefer somewhat more action on content from liberal sources, and vice versa. We also find that judgments about two holistic properties, misleadingness and harm, could serve as an effective proxy to determine what actions would be approved by a majority of raters.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑