是否有偏见:两个搜索引擎的故事
Biased or Not?: The Story of Two Search Engines
摘要:
搜索引擎可以被认为是通往WEB世界的大门,它们也决定了我们在给定的搜索查询中看到的内容。由于许多人通过搜索引擎接触到信息,因此期望搜索引擎应该是中立的是公平的;即返回的结果必须涵盖搜索主题的所有元素或方面,并且在基于相关性返回结果时应该是公正的。然而,搜索引擎的结果是基于许多功能和复杂的算法,其中搜索中立性不一定是焦点。在这项工作中,我们进行了实证研究,两个流行的搜索引擎和分析的搜索引擎结果页有争议的话题,如堕胎,医用大麻,同性恋婚姻。我们的分析是基于搜索结果中的情绪,以确定他们的观点是保守还是自由。我们还提出了三个基于情感的指标来显示偏见的存在,以及比较两个搜索引擎的观点。对有争议的主题进行的大量实验表明,两个搜索引擎都有偏见,而且它们对给定的有争议的主题有相同的偏见。
英文摘要:
Search engines can be considered as a gate to the world of WEB, and they also decide what we see for a given search query. Since many people are exposed to information through search engines, it is fair to expect that search engines should be neutral; i.e. the returned results must cover all the elements or aspects of the search topic, and they should be impartial where the results are returned based on relevance. However, the search engine results are based on many features and sophisticated algorithms where search neutrality is not necessarily the focal point. In this work we performed an empirical study on two popular search engines and analysed the search engine result pages for controversial topics such as abortion, medical marijuana, and gay marriage. Our analysis is based on the sentiment in search results to identify their viewpoint as conservative or liberal. We also propose three sentiment-based metrics to show the existence of bias as well as to compare viewpoints of the two search engines. Extensive experiments performed on controversial topics show that both search engines are biased, moreover they have the same kind of bias towards a given controversial topic.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。