arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2108.13080physics.ed-ph
收藏

使用计算论文重新分配本科科学中的认识能动性

Using Computational Essays to Redistribute Epistemic Agency in Undergraduate Science

Tor Ole B. Odden, Devin Silvia, Anders Malthe-Sørenssen

摘要:

本文报道了一项研究,调查如何计算论文可以用来重新分配认知机构-认知控制和对自己的学习责任-在高等教育STEM的学生。计算论文是一种科学写作类型,它将可执行的实时计算机代码与叙述性文本相结合,以呈现计算模型或分析。这项研究发生在两个对比鲜明的大学环境中:美国密歇根州立大学的跨学科数据科学和建模课程,以及挪威奥斯陆大学的第三学期物理课程。在一个学期的课程中,计算论文同时独立地用于两门课程,并从两个学生群体中收集了学生工件和回顾性访谈的可比数据集。这些数据进行了分析,使用的框架,可操作的结构,认知机构的规划,查询,数据分析和建模,和通信的尺寸。基于这一分析,我们认为,计算论文可以是一个有用的工具,在重新分配认识机构的学生在高等教育科学,由于其相结合的适应性和学科的真实性。然而,我们也认为,教育背景,脚手架,期望和学生的背景可以限制和影响学生选择采取认知机构的方式。

英文摘要:

This article reports on a study investigating how computational essays can be used to redistribute epistemic agency--cognitive control and responsibility over one's own learning--to students in higher education STEM. Computational essays are a genre of scientific writing that combine live, executable computer code with narrative text to present a computational model or analysis. The study took place across two contrasting university contexts: an interdisciplinary data science and modeling course at Michigan State University, USA, and a third-semester physics course at the University of Oslo, Norway. Over the course of a semester, computational essays were simultaneously and independently used in both courses, and comparable datasets of student artifacts and retrospective interviews were collected from both student populations. These data were analyzed using a framework which operationalized the construct of epistemic agency across the dimensions of programming, inquiry, data analysis and modeling, and communication. Based on this analysis, we argue that computational essays can be a useful tool in redistributing epistemic agency to students within higher education science due to their combination of adaptability and disciplinary authenticity. However, we also argue that educational contexts, scaffolding, expectations, and student backgrounds can constrain and influence the ways in which students choose to take up epistemic agency.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑