arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2106.00810cs.LGstat.ML
收藏

机器学习会议评审过程中的若干伦理问题

Some Ethical Issues in the Review Process of Machine Learning Conferences

KTH Royal Institute of Technology(瑞典皇家理工学院)

Alessio Russo

摘要:

机器学习社区最近的成功导致提交给会议的论文数量急剧增加。这一增加使影响这些会议目前所使用的审查程序的一些问题更加突出。审查过程中有几个问题可能会破坏科学研究的性质,即完全客观,非政治性,无偏见和无不当行为(如剽窃,作弊,不当影响和其他不当行为)。在这项工作中,我们研究了审稿人的招聘问题,双盲过程的违规行为,欺诈行为,数字评级的偏见,以及附录现象(即,在论文的附录部分公布研究结果的做法越来越普遍)。对于每一个问题,我们提供了一个简短的描述和可能的解决方案。这项工作的目标是提高机器学习社区对这些问题的认识。

英文摘要:

Recent successes in the Machine Learning community have led to a steep increase in the number of papers submitted to conferences. This increase made more prominent some of the issues that affect the current review process used by these conferences. The review process has several issues that may undermine the nature of scientific research, which is of being fully objective, apolitical, unbiased and free of misconduct (such as plagiarism, cheating, improper influence, and other improprieties). In this work, we study the problem of reviewers' recruitment, infringements of the double-blind process, fraudulent behaviors, biases in numerical ratings, and the appendix phenomenon (i.e., the fact that it is becoming more common to publish results in the appendix section of a paper). For each of these problems, we provide a short description and possible solutions. The goal of this work is to raise awareness in the Machine Learning community regarding these issues.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑