arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2102.02945econ.EM
收藏

规定选择实验中的假设偏倚:部分II。文献的宏观分析和偏倚缓解方法的有效性

Hypothetical bias in stated choice experiments: Part II. Macro-scale analysis of literature and effectiveness of bias mitigation methods

Milad Haghani, Michiel C. J. Bliemer, John M. Rose, Harmen Oppewal, Emily Lancsar

摘要:

本文综述了选择实验中消除假设偏差的方法。它提出了一个文献计量分析和总结的经验证据,他们的有效性。本文遵循本研究第一部分中提出的HB存在的经验证据的审查。虽然自2010年以来CE研究的数量迅速增加,但仅在一小部分CE研究中研究了HB的关键问题。本综述包括事前和事后偏倚缓解方法。事前偏见缓解方法包括廉价谈话,真正的谈话,后果脚本,庄严的誓言脚本,选择退出提醒,预算提醒,诚实启动,诱导说实话,间接提问,思考时间和枢轴设计。事后方法包括后续的确定性校准量表,受访者感知的后果量表,和显示偏好辅助估计。据观察,缓解方法的使用在应用经济学的不同部门之间存在显著差异。现有的经验证据表明,它们在降低HB方面的总体效果,尽管存在一些差异。本文进一步讨论了每种缓解方法如何对抗HB源的某个子集。考虑到HB在CE中的患病率和偏倚缓解方法的有效性,建议实施至少一种偏倚缓解方法(或适当的组合,如可能)成为执行CE的标准实践。应实施适合特定应用的缓解方法,以确保推理和随后的策略决策尽可能不受HB影响。

英文摘要:

This paper reviews methods of hypothetical bias (HB) mitigation in choice experiments (CEs). It presents a bibliometric analysis and summary of empirical evidence of their effectiveness. The paper follows the review of empirical evidence on the existence of HB presented in Part I of this study. While the number of CE studies has rapidly increased since 2010, the critical issue of HB has been studied in only a small fraction of CE studies. The present review includes both ex-ante and ex-post bias mitigation methods. Ex-ante bias mitigation methods include cheap talk, real talk, consequentiality scripts, solemn oath scripts, opt-out reminders, budget reminders, honesty priming, induced truth telling, indirect questioning, time to think and pivot designs. Ex-post methods include follow-up certainty calibration scales, respondent perceived consequentiality scales, and revealed-preference-assisted estimation. It is observed that the use of mitigation methods markedly varies across different sectors of applied economics. The existing empirical evidence points to their overall effectives in reducing HB, although there is some variation. The paper further discusses how each mitigation method can counter a certain subset of HB sources. Considering the prevalence of HB in CEs and the effectiveness of bias mitigation methods, it is recommended that implementation of at least one bias mitigation method (or a suitable combination where possible) becomes standard practice in conducting CEs. Mitigation method(s) suited to the particular application should be implemented to ensure that inferences and subsequent policy decisions are as much as possible free of HB.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑