arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2102.02940econ.EM
收藏

陈述选择实验中的假设偏差:第一部分。经验证据的综合合成和外部效度的概念化

Hypothetical bias in stated choice experiments: Part I. Integrative synthesis of empirical evidence and conceptualisation of external validity

Milad Haghani, Michiel C. J. Bliemer, John M. Rose, Harmen Oppewal, Emily Lancsar

摘要:

假设性偏差的概念可以说是使用假设性调查方法的最基本问题。调查参与者的选择和随后推断的估计是否或在多大程度上转化为现实世界的环境仍在争论之中。虽然HB已被广泛研究在更广泛的背景下或有价值,它是少得多的理解与选择实验(CE)。本文回顾了在应用经济学的各个领域的实证证据,在CE HB,并提出了一个综合框架,HB与外部效度。结果表明,混合证据的患病率,程度和方向HB以及相当大的背景和测量依赖性。虽然HB被发现是一个不可否认的问题时,进行CE,HB的经验证据并没有使CE无法代表现实世界的偏好。虽然健康相关的选择实验往往发现HB的程度可以忽略不计,在消费者行为和运输领域的实验表明,显着程度的HB是无处不在的。对环境估价研究中的偏见的评估提供了各种证据。此外,在这些学科中,许多研究显示HB在他们的总愿意支付估计和选择率,但不是在他们假设的边际替代率(受规模校正)。此外,心理学和脑成像研究的最新发现表明,HB的神经认知机制可能解释了主流CE文献中的一些差异和意外发现。审查还观察到HB的业务定义的多样性如何禁止在CE HB的一致测量。本文进一步确定了HB的主要来源和可能的调节因素。最后,它解释了HB是如何代表外部效度这一更广泛概念的一个组成部分的。

英文摘要:

The notion of hypothetical bias (HB) constitutes, arguably, the most fundamental issue in relation to the use of hypothetical survey methods. Whether or to what extent choices of survey participants and subsequent inferred estimates translate to real-world settings continues to be debated. While HB has been extensively studied in the broader context of contingent valuation, it is much less understood in relation to choice experiments (CE). This paper reviews the empirical evidence for HB in CE in various fields of applied economics and presents an integrative framework for how HB relates to external validity. Results suggest mixed evidence on the prevalence, extent and direction of HB as well as considerable context and measurement dependency. While HB is found to be an undeniable issue when conducting CEs, the empirical evidence on HB does not render CEs unable to represent real-world preferences. While health-related choice experiments often find negligible degrees of HB, experiments in consumer behaviour and transport domains suggest that significant degrees of HB are ubiquitous. Assessments of bias in environmental valuation studies provide mixed evidence. Also, across these disciplines many studies display HB in their total willingness to pay estimates and opt-in rates but not in their hypothetical marginal rates of substitution (subject to scale correction). Further, recent findings in psychology and brain imaging studies suggest neurocognitive mechanisms underlying HB that may explain some of the discrepancies and unexpected findings in the mainstream CE literature. The review also observes how the variety of operational definitions of HB prohibits consistent measurement of HB in CE. The paper further identifies major sources of HB and possible moderating factors. Finally, it explains how HB represents one component of the wider concept of external validity.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑