是时候重新审视终点稀释法,并取代TCID$_{50}$和PFU作为病毒样本感染浓度的衡量指标
Time to revisit the endpoint dilution assay and to replace TCID$_{50}$ and PFU as measures of a virus sample's infection concentration
AI总结:
本文提出用SIN指标取代PFU、FFU和ID$_{50}$来衡量病毒样本感染浓度,并开发了免费开源网络应用midSIN,在不改变现有实验方案的前提下从标准终点稀释实验中更准确、稳健地计算SIN浓度。
摘要:
病毒样本的感染性通过其引起的感染来衡量,方法包括噬斑或病灶形成实验(PFU或FFU)或终点稀释(ED)实验(TCID$_{50}$、CCID$_{50}$、EID$_{50}$等,以下统称ID$_{50}$)。在给定稀释度下计数噬斑或病灶,直观且直接地提供了未稀释样本中感染剂量的浓度。然而,该方法存在许多技术和实验上的局限性。例如,它依赖于实验者判断两个合并的噬斑与一个较大噬斑之间的区别,或小噬斑与染色伪影之间的区别。在这方面,ED实验更为稳健,因为只需判断感染是否发生。ED实验的输出,即50%感染剂量(ID$_{50}$),使用Spearman-Karber(SK,1908,1931)或Reed-Muench(RM,1938)数学近似方法计算。然而,这些计算经常出错,且其ID$_{50}$近似存在偏差。我们建议放弃PFU和FFU实验,并将ED实验的测量输出ID$_{50}$替换为我们创造的一种更有用的衡量指标,称为Specific INfections(SIN)。我们介绍了一个免费、开源的网络应用程序midSIN,它可以从标准ED实验中计算病毒样本中的SIN浓度,无需改变当前的实验方案。我们证明,样本的SIN/mL可靠地对应于该样本每单位体积将引起的感染数量,并直接与感染复数相关。研究表明,midSIN的估计比使用RM和SK近似的估计更准确、更稳健。本文还探讨了ED板设计选择(稀释因子、每个稀释度的重复次数)对测量准确性的影响。SIN作为衡量指标的简洁性以及midSIN更高的准确性,使其成为PFU、FFU和ID$_{50}$衡量指标的简便且优越的替代方案。
英文摘要:
The infectivity of a virus sample is measured by the infections it causes, via a plaque or focus forming assay (PFU or FFU) or an endpoint dilution (ED) assay (TCID$_{50}$, CCID$_{50}$, EID$_{50}$, etc., hereafter collectively ID$_{50}$). The counting of plaques or foci at a given dilution intuitively and directly provides the concentration of infectious doses in the undiluted sample. However, it has many technical and experimental limitations. For example, it relies on one's judgement in distinguishing between two merged plaques and a larger one, or between small plaques and staining artifacts. In this regard, ED assays are more robust because one need only determine whether infection occurred. The output of the ED assay, the 50% infectious dose (ID$_{50}$), is calculated using either the Spearman-Karber (SK, 1908,1931) or Reed-Muench (RM, 1938) mathematical approximations. However, these are often miscalculated and their ID$_{50}$ approximation is biased. We propose that the PFU and FFU assays be abandoned, and that the measured output of the ED assay, the ID$_{50}$, be replaced by a more useful measure we coined Specific INfections (SIN). We introduce a free, open-source web-application, midSIN, that computes the SIN concentration in a virus sample from a standard ED assay, requiring no changes to current experimental protocols. We demonstrate that the SIN/mL of a sample reliably corresponds to the number of infections the sample will cause per unit volume, and directly relates to the multiplicity of infection. midSIN estimates are shown to be more accurate and robust than those using the RM and SK approximations. The impact of ED plate design choices (dilution factor, replicates per dilution) on measurement accuracy is also explored. The simplicity of SIN as a measure and the greater accuracy of midSIN make them an easy, superior replacement for the PFU, FFU, and ID$_{50}$ measures.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。