arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2101.11298cs.CL
收藏

如何评价一个摘要器:手工语言质量评价的研究设计与统计分析

How to Evaluate a Summarizer: Study Design and Statistical Analysis for Manual Linguistic Quality Evaluation

Heidelberg University(海德堡大学)

Julius Steen, Katja Markert

摘要:

人工评估是判断自动文本摘要进展的关键。然而,我们进行了一项调查,最近的摘要系统的论文,揭示了如何进行这种评估研究的协议。我们对摘要的语言质量(连贯性和重复性)的两个方面进行了两个评价实验,比较了Likert类型和等级注释,并表明最佳评价方法的选择可以从一个方面到另一个方面而变化。在我们的调查中,我们还发现,研究参数,如注释者的总数和注释者的注释项目的分布往往没有完全报告,随后的统计分析忽略了分组因素所产生的一个注释判断多个摘要。使用我们的评估实验,我们表明,注释器的总数可以有很大的影响,学习的力量,目前的统计分析方法可以膨胀I型出错率高达8倍。此外,我们强调,为了系统比较的目的,目前的做法,每个摘要引起多个判断,导致不太强大和可靠的注释给定一个固定的研究预算。

英文摘要:

Manual evaluation is essential to judge progress on automatic text summarization. However, we conduct a survey on recent summarization system papers that reveals little agreement on how to perform such evaluation studies. We conduct two evaluation experiments on two aspects of summaries' linguistic quality (coherence and repetitiveness) to compare Likert-type and ranking annotations and show that best choice of evaluation method can vary from one aspect to another. In our survey, we also find that study parameters such as the overall number of annotators and distribution of annotators to annotation items are often not fully reported and that subsequent statistical analysis ignores grouping factors arising from one annotator judging multiple summaries. Using our evaluation experiments, we show that the total number of annotators can have a strong impact on study power and that current statistical analysis methods can inflate type I error rates up to eight-fold. In addition, we highlight that for the purpose of system comparison the current practice of eliciting multiple judgements per summary leads to less powerful and reliable annotations given a fixed study budget.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑