arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2101.00280cs.AI
收藏

任意决策理论的一个一般反例及其对策

A General Counterexample to Any Decision Theory and Some Responses

Oxford University(牛津大学)

Joar Skalse

摘要:

在本文中,我提出了一个参数和一个一般模式,可以用来构建一个问题的情况下,任何决策理论,在某种程度上,可以采取表明,一个不能制定决策理论,从来没有优于任何其他决策理论。我也提出并讨论了一些可能的回应这一论点。其中一个回答提出了两个决策问题在相关意义上“等价”意味着什么的问题,并给出了这个问题的答案,这将使第一个论点无效。然而,这一立场将有进一步的后果,我们如何比较不同的决策理论在决策问题已经讨论过的文献(包括例如纽科姆的问题)。

英文摘要:

In this paper I present an argument and a general schema which can be used to construct a problem case for any decision theory, in a way that could be taken to show that one cannot formulate a decision theory that is never outperformed by any other decision theory. I also present and discuss a number of possible responses to this argument. One of these responses raises the question of what it means for two decision problems to be "equivalent" in the relevant sense, and gives an answer to this question which would invalidate the first argument. However, this position would have further consequences for how we compare different decision theories in decision problems already discussed in the literature (including e.g. Newcomb's problem).

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑