学术界的女性:从天文学角度对性别研究中的选择偏见发出警告
Women in academia: a warning on selection bias in gender studies from the astronomical perspective
摘要:
AlShebli等人(2020)最近的论文调查了导师制对年轻科学家的影响。他们在结论中指出,女学生从男性指导中受益比从女性指导中受益更多。我们在此揭露了他们的方法设计中的一个关键缺陷,这是天文学中的一个常见问题,即“选择偏差”。如果不正确处理,可能导致不必要的因果关系声明的影响。在他们的分析中,选择偏差似乎存在于他们的调查的回答率(8.35%),数据库的选择,成功的标准,以及忽视了女性研究人员在学术界面临的众多缺点。我们讨论这些问题及其影响-其中之一是在学术界的妇女的障碍的潜在增加。最后,我们强调了在旨在检索因果关系的研究中不考虑选择偏差效应的危险。
英文摘要:
The recent paper by AlShebli et al. (2020) investigates the impact of mentorship in young scientists. Among their conclusions, they state that female protégés benefit more from male than female mentorship. We herein expose a critical flaw in their methodological design that is a common issue in Astronomy, namely "selection biases". An effect that if not treated properly may lead to unwarranted causality claims. In their analysis, selection biases seem to be present in the response rate of their survey (8.35%), the choice of database, success criterion, and the overlook of the numerous drawbacks female researchers face in academia. We discuss these issues and their implications -- one of them being the potential increase in obstacles for women in academia. Finally, we reinforce the dangers of not considering selection bias effects in studies aimed at retrieving causal relations.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。