arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2012.08347cs.CRcs.CY
收藏

超越隐私权衡:结构化透明度

Beyond Privacy Trade-offs with Structured Transparency

Andrew Trask, Emma Bluemke, Teddy Collins, Ben Garfinkel Eric Drexler, Claudia Ghezzou Cuervas-Mons, Iason Gabriel, Allan Dafoe, William Isaac

AI总结:

针对信息共享中的“复制问题”及其捆绑、编辑和递归执行难题,论文提出五部分“结构化透明度”框架,整合分散领域的信息流治理能力以促进协作。

摘要:

成功的协作离不开信息共享。然而,各方可能对其所需共享的信息应如何被使用存在分歧。我们认为,这些担忧中有许多可归结为“复制问题”:一旦一条信息被复制并共享,发送方就无法再控制接收方如何使用它。从每个协作者的角度来看,这造成了一种可能抑制协作的困境。复制问题往往会因三个相关问题而加剧,我们将其称为捆绑问题、编辑问题和递归执行问题。我们发现,尽管复制问题无法解决,但这些加剧问题的各个方面已在多个彼此割裂的领域中得到处理。我们观察到,将这些努力结合起来可以提升信息流的可治理性,从而激励协作。我们提出了一个由五部分组成的框架,将这些努力归入具体能力,并为将其整合进一个我们称为“结构化透明度”的总体愿景提供基础。最后,我们调研了一系列用例,用以说明结构化透明度原则及其相关能力。

英文摘要:

Successful collaboration involves sharing information. However, parties may disagree on how the information they need to share should be used. We argue that many of these concerns reduce to 'the copy problem': once a bit of information is copied and shared, the sender can no longer control how the recipient uses it. From the perspective of each collaborator, this presents a dilemma that can inhibit collaboration. The copy problem is often amplified by three related problems which we term the bundling, edit, and recursive enforcement problems. We find that while the copy problem is not solvable, aspects of these amplifying problems have been addressed in a variety of disconnected fields. We observe that combining these efforts could improve the governability of information flows and thereby incentivise collaboration. We propose a five-part framework which groups these efforts into specific capabilities and offers a foundation for their integration into an overarching vision we call "structured transparency". We conclude by surveying an array of use-cases that illustrate the structured transparency principles and their related capabilities.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑