\emph{Focused sequent calculi} are a refinement of sequent calculi, where additional side-conditions on the applicability of inference rules force the implementation of a proof search strategy. Focused cut-free proofs exhibit a special normal form that is used for defining identity of sequent calculi proofs. We introduce a novel focused display calculus fD.LG and a fully polarized algebraic semantics FP.LG for Lambek-Grishin logic by generalizing the theory of \emph{multi-type calculi} and their algebraic semantics with \emph{heterogenous consequence relations}. The calculus fD.LG has \emph{strong focalization} and it is \emph{sound and complete} w.r.t. FP.LG. This completeness result is in a sense stronger than completeness with respect to standard polarized algebraic semantics (see e.g. the phase semantics of Bastenhof for Lambek-Grishin logic or Hamano and Takemura for linear logic), insofar we do not need to quotient over proofs with consecutive applications of shifts over the same formula. We plan to investigate the connections, if any, between this completeness result and the notion of \emph{full completeness} introduced by Abramsky et al. We also show a number of additional results. fD.LG is sound and complete w.r.t. LG-algebras: this amounts to a semantic proof of the so-called \emph{completeness of focusing}, given that the standard (display) sequent calculus for Lambek-Grishin logic is complete w.r.t. LG-algebras. fD.LG and the focused calculus f.LG of Moortgat and Moot are equivalent with respect to proofs, indeed there is an effective translation from f.LG-derivations to fD.LG-derivations and vice versa: this provides the link with operational semantics, given that every f.LG-derivation is in a Curry-Howard correspondence with a directional $\overlineλμ\widetildeμ$-term.
Every language recognized by the Lambek calculus with brackets is context-free. This is shown by combining an observation by Jäger with an entirely straightforward adaptation of the method Pentus used for the original Lambek calculus. The case of the variant of the calculus allowing sequents with empty antecedents is slightly more complicated, requiring a restricted use of the multiplicative unit.
We present a translation of the Lambek calculus with brackets and the unit constant, $\mathbf{Lb}^{\boldsymbol{*}}_{\mathbf{1}}$, into the Lambek calculus with brackets allowing empty antecedents, but without the unit constant, $\mathbf{Lb}^{\boldsymbol{*}}$. Using this translation, we extend previously known results for $\mathbf{Lb}^{\boldsymbol{*}}$ to $\mathbf{Lb}^{\boldsymbol{*}}_{\mathbf{1}}$: (1) languages generated by categorial grammars based on the Lambek calculus with brackets are context-free (Kanazawa 2017); (2) the polynomial-time algorithm for deciding derivability of bounded dep…
In this paper hypergraph Lambek calculus ($\mathrm{HL}$) is presented. This formalism aims to generalize the Lambek calculus ($\mathrm{L}$) to hypergraphs as hyperedge replacement grammars extend context-free grammars. In contrast to the Lambek calculus, $\mathrm{HL}$ deals with hypergraph types and sequents; its axioms and rules naturally generalize those of $\mathrm{L}$. Consequently, certain properties (e.g. the cut elimination) can be lifted from $\mathrm{L}$ to $\mathrm{HL}$. It is shown that $\mathrm{L}$ can be naturally embedded in $\mathrm{HL}$; moreover, a number of its variants ($\ma…
In this paper, we consider the polymodal version of Lambek calculus with subexponential modalities initially introduced by Kanovich, Kuznetsov, Nigam, and Scedrov and its quantale semantics. In our approach, subexponential modalities have an interpretation in terms of quantic conuclei. We show that this extension of Lambek calculus is complete w.r.t quantales with quantic conuclei. Also, we prove a representation theorem for quantales with quantic conuclei and show that Lambek calculus with subexponentials is relationally complete. Finally, we extend this representation theorem to the category…
We investigate language interpretations of two extensions of the Lambek calculus: with additive conjunction and disjunction and with additive conjunction and the unit constant. For extensions with additive connectives, we show that conjunction and disjunction behave differently. Adding both of them leads to incompleteness due to the distributivity law. We show that with conjunction only no issues with distributivity arise. In contrast, there exists a corollary of the distributivity law in the language with disjunction only which is not derivable in the non-distributive system. Moreover, this d…
We give a proof-theoretic and algorithmic complexity analysis for systems introduced by Morrill to serve as the core of the CatLog categorial grammar parser. We consider two recent versions of Morrill's calculi, and focus on their fragments including multiplicative (Lambek) connectives, additive conjunction and disjunction, brackets and bracket modalities, and the ! subexponential modality. For both systems, we resolve issues connected with the cut rule and provide necessary modifications, after which we prove admissibility of cut (cut elimination theorem). We also prove algorithmic undecidabi…
It is known that context-free grammars can be extended to generating graphs resulting in graph grammars; one of such fundamental approaches is hyperedge replacement grammars. On the other hand there are type-logical grammars which also serve to describe string languages. In this paper, we investigate how to extend the Lambek calculus ($\mathrm{L}$) and grammars based on it to graphs. The resulting approach is called hypergraph Lambek calculus ($\mathrm{HL}$). It is a logical sequential calculus whose sequents are graphs; it naturally extends the Lambek calculus and also allows one to embed its…
We enrich the Lambek calculus with the cyclic shift operation, which is expected to model the closure operator of formal languages with respect to cyclic shifts. We introduce a Gentzen-style calculus and prove cut elimination. Secondly, we turn to categorial grammars based on this calculus and show that they can generate non-context-free languages; besides, we consider a related calculus where the cyclic shift is a structural rule, and compare recognizing power of these two calculi. Thirdly, we attempt to embed the Lambek calculus with the cyclic shift operation in the hypergraph Lambek calcul…
In this paper, we introduce a variant of the Lambek calculus allowing empty antecedents. This variant uses two connecives: the left division and a unary modality that occurs only with negative polarity and allows weakening in antecedents of sequents. We define the notion of a proof net for this calculus, which is similar to those for the ordinary Lambek calculus and multiplicative linear logic. We prove that a sequent is derivable in the calculus under consideration if and only if there exists a proof net for it. Thus, we establish a derivability criterion for this calculus in terms of the exi…
This paper introduces a natural deduction calculus for intuitionistic logic of belief $\mathsf{IEL}^{-}$ which is easily turned into a modal $λ$-calculus giving a computational semantics for deductions in $\mathsf{IEL}^{-}$. By using that interpretation, it is also proved that $\mathsf{IEL}^{-}$ has good proof-theoretic properties. The correspondence between deductions and typed terms is then extended to a categorical semantics for identity of proofs in $\mathsf{IEL}^{-}$ showing the general structure of such a modality for belief in an intuitionistic framework.
University College London（伦敦大学学院）；National Research University Higher School of Economics（俄罗斯国家研究型高等经济大学）；Steklov Mathematical Institute, RAS（俄罗斯科学院斯捷克洛夫数学研究所）；University of Pennsylvania（宾夕法尼亚大学）
The Lambek calculus is a well-known logical formalism for modelling natural language syntax. The original calculus covered a substantial number of intricate natural language phenomena, but only those restricted to the context-free setting. In order to address more subtle linguistic issues, the Lambek calculus has been extended in various ways. In particular, Morrill and Valentin (2015) introduce an extension with so-called exponential and bracket modalities. Their extension is based on a non-standard contraction rule for the exponential that interacts with the bracket structure in an intricate…
University College London（伦敦大学学院）；National Research University Higher School of Economics（国立研究型高等经济学院）；Steklov Mathematical Institute（斯捷克洛夫数学研究所）；University of Pennsylvania（宾夕法尼亚大学）
The Lambek calculus can be considered as a version of non-commutative intuitionistic linear logic. One of the interesting features of the Lambek calculus is the so-called "Lambek's restriction," that is, the antecedent of any provable sequent should be non-empty. In this paper we discuss ways of extending the Lambek calculus with the linear logic exponential modality while keeping Lambek's restriction. Interestingly enough, we show that for any system equipped with a reasonable exponential modality the following holds: if the system enjoys cut elimination and substitution to the full extent, t…
In this paper, we study logics of bounded distributive residuated lattices with modal operators considering $\Box$ and $\Diamond$ in a noncommutative setting. We introduce relational semantics for such substructural modal logics. We prove that any canonical logic is Kripke complete via discrete duality and canonical extensions. That is, we show that a modal extension of the distributive full Lambek calculus is the logic of its frames if its variety is closed under canonical extensions. After that, we establish a Priestley-style duality between residuated distributive modal algebras and topolog…
National Research University Higher School of Economics（俄罗斯国家研究型高等经济大学）
We consider tensor grammars, which are an example of \commutative" grammars, based on the classical (rather than intuitionistic) linear logic. They can be seen as a surface representation of abstract categorial grammars ACG in the sense that derivations of ACG translate to derivations of tensor grammars and this translation is isomorphic on the level of string languages. The basic ingredient are tensor terms, which can be seen as encoding and generalizing proof-nets. Using tensor terms makes the syntax extremely simple and a direct geometric meaning becomes transparent. Then we address the pro…
The Distributional Compositional Categorical (DisCoCat) model is a mathematical framework that provides compositional semantics for meanings of natural language sentences. It consists of a computational procedure for constructing meanings of sentences, given their grammatical structure in terms of compositional type-logic, and given the empirically derived meanings of their words. For the particular case that the meaning of words is modelled within a distributional vector space model, its experimental predictions, derived from real large scale data, have outperformed other empirically validate…
Formulae of the Lambek calculus are constructed using three binary connectives, multiplication and two divisions. We extend it using a unary connective, positive Kleene iteration. For this new operation, following its natural interpretation, we present two lines of calculi. The first one is a fragment of infinitary action logic and includes an omega-rule for introducing iteration to the antecedent. We also consider a version with infinite (but finitely branching) derivations and prove equivalence of these two versions. In Kleene algebras, this line of calculi corresponds to the *-continuous ca…
University College London（伦敦大学学院）；National Research University Higher School of Economics（国立研究大学高等经济学院）；Steklov Mathematical Institute（斯捷克洛夫数学研究所）；University of Pennsylvania（宾夕法尼亚大学）
Morrill and Valentin in the paper "Computational coverage of TLG: Nonlinearity" considered an extension of the Lambek calculus enriched by a so-called "exponential" modality. This modality behaves in the "relevant" style, that is, it allows contraction and permutation, but not weakening. Morrill and Valentin stated an open problem whether this system is decidable. Here we show its undecidability. Our result remains valid if we consider the fragment where all division operations have one direction. We also show that the derivability problem in a restricted case, where the modality can be applie…
We develop a vector space semantics for verb phrase ellipsis with anaphora using type-driven compositional distributional semantics based on the Lambek calculus with limited contraction (LCC) of Jäger (2006). Distributional semantics has a lot to say about the statistical collocation-based meanings of content words, but provides little guidance on how to treat function words. Formal semantics on the other hand, has powerful mechanisms for dealing with relative pronouns, coordinators, and the like. Type-driven compositional distributional semantics brings these two models together. We review pr…
Thirty years ago, I introduced a non-commutative variant of classical linear logic, called "pomset logic", issued from a particular categorical interpretation of linear logic known as coherence spaces. In addition to the usual commutative multiplicative connectives of linear logic, pomset logic includes a non-commutative connective, "$\triangleleft$" called "before", associative and self-dual: $(A\triangleleft B)^\perp=A^\perp \triangleleft B^\perp$. The conclusion of a pomset logic proof is a Partially Ordered MultiSET of formulas. Pomset logic enjoys a proof net calculus with cut-elimination…
We prove that all axiomatic extensions of the full Lambek calculus with exchange can be axiomatized by formulas on the $\mathcal N_3$ level of the substructural hierarchy.
In this paper we study some fragments without implications of the (Hilbert) full Lambek logic $\mathbf{HFL}$ and also some fragments without implications of some of the substructural extensions of that logic. To do this, we perform an algebraic analysis of the Gentzen systems defined by the substructural calculi $\FL_σ$. Such systems are extensions of the full Lambek calculus $\FL$ with the rules codified by a subsequence, $σ$, of the sequence $e w_l w_r c$; where $e$ stands for \emph{exchange}, $w_l$ for \emph{left weakening}, $w_r$ for \emph{right weakening}, and $c$ for \emph{contraction}. …
The unified correspondence theory for distributive lattice expansion logics (DLE-logics) is specialized to strict implication logics. As a consequence of a general semantic consevativity result, a wide range of strict implication logics can be conservatively extended to Lambek Calculi over the bounded distributive full non-associative Lambek calculus (BDFNL). Many strict implication sequents can be transformed into analytic rules employing one of the main tools of unified correspondence theory, namely (a suitably modified version of) the Ackermann lemma based algorithm $\msf{ALBA}$. Gentzen-st…
LIRMM（蒙彼利埃大学与法国国家科学研究中心联合计算机科学、机器人与微电子实验室）；Université de Montpellier（蒙彼利埃大学）；CNRS（法国国家科学研究中心）；The Ohio State University（俄亥俄州立大学）
This paper explores proof-theoretic aspects of hybrid type-logical grammars , a logic combining Lambek grammars with lambda grammars. We prove some basic properties of the calculus, such as normalisation and the subformula property and also present both a sequent and a proof net calculus for hybrid type-logical grammars. In addition to clarifying the logical foundations of hybrid type-logical grammars, the current study opens the way to variants and extensions of the original system, including but not limited to a non-associative version and a multimodal version incorporating structural rules …
We introduce proper display calculi for intuitionistic, bi-intuitionistic and classical linear logics with exponentials, which are sound, complete, conservative, and enjoy cut-elimination and subformula property. Based on the same design, we introduce a variant of Lambek calculus with exponentials, aimed at capturing the controlled application of exchange and associativity. Properness (i.e. closure under uniform substitution of all parametric parts in rules) is the main interest and added value of the present proposal, and allows for the smoothest proof of cut-elimination. Our proposal builds …
We introduce a sequent calculus FL' for non-commutative substructural logic. It has at most one formula on the right side of sequent, and excludes three structural inference rules, i.e. contraction, weakening and exchange. (FL' is based on our investigations of the Gentzen-style natural deduction for non-commutative substructural logics.) FL' has the same proof strength as the standard sequent calculus FL (Full Lambek), which is the basic sequent calculus for all other substructural logics. For the standard FL, we use Ono's formulation. Although FL' and the standard FL are equivalent, there is…
