Choosing a publication venue for an academic paper is a crucial step in the research process. However, in many cases, decisions are based solely on the experience of researchers, which often leads to suboptimal results. Although there exist venue recommender systems for academic papers, they recommend venues where the paper is expected to be published. In this study, we aim to recommend publication venues from a different perspective. We estimate the number of citations a paper will receive if the paper is published in each venue and recommend the venue where the paper has the most potential impact. However, there are two challenges to this task. First, a paper is published in only one venue, and thus, we cannot observe the number of citations the paper would receive if the paper were published in another venue. Secondly, the contents of a paper and the publication venue are not statistically independent; that is, there exist selection biases in choosing publication venues. In this paper, we formulate the venue recommendation problem as a treatment effect estimation problem. We use a bias correction method to estimate the potential impact of choosing a publication venue effectively and to recommend venues based on the potential impact of papers in each venue. We highlight the effectiveness of our method using paper data from computer science conferences.
Consensus and fragmentation in academic publication preferences
University of Colorado Boulder(科罗拉多大学博尔德分校);Copenhagen Center for Social Data Science, University of Copenhagen(哥本哈根大学社会数据科学中心);Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences, University of Colorado Boulder(科罗拉多大学博尔德分校环境科学研究合作研究所);Stanford Doerr School of Sustainability, Stanford University(斯坦福大学道尔可持续发展学院);Department of Statistics & Data Science, Yale University(耶鲁大学统计与数据科学系);BioFrontiers Institute, University of Colorado Boulder(科罗拉多大学博尔德分校生物前沿研究所);Santa Fe Institute(圣塔菲研究所)
PreprintMatch: a tool for preprint publication detection applied to analyze global inequities in scientific publishing
预印本,即同行评议之前的科学手稿版本,越来越受欢迎。它们提供了一个民主化和加速研究的机会,因为它们没有出版成本或漫长的同行评审过程。预印本通常随后在同行评审的场所出版,但这些出版物和原始预印本通常没有任何联系。为此,我们开发了一个工具PreprintMatch,用于查找预印本及其相应的已发表论文(如果存在)之间的匹配。该工具在匹配性能和速度方面都优于现有的预印本和纸张匹配技术。应用PreprintMatch搜索预印本(来自bioRxiv和medRxiv)与PubMed之间的匹配。预印本的初步性质在相对早期的阶段为科学项目提供了一个独特的视角,并且预印本和论文之间有了更好的匹配,我们探讨了与研究不平等相关的问题。我们发现,来自低收入国家的预印本作为同行评议论文发表的比例低于高收入国家(分别为39.6%和61.1%),我们的数据与以前的工作一致,这些工作引用了缺乏资源,缺乏稳定性和政策选择来解释这种差异。来自低收入国家的预印本也被发现出版更快(178 vs 203天),与高收入国家相比,标题,摘要和作者与出版版本的相似性更少。低收入国家比高收入国家增加了更多的作者(分别为0.42和0.32),这种做法在中国比类似国家更常见。最后,我们发现一些出版商比其他出版商更频繁地出版来自低收入国家的作者的作品。预印匹配可在\url{https://github.com/PeterEckmann1/…