arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2009.02776stat.APstat.ME
收藏

Matching Bounds:匹配算法的选择如何影响处理效应估计以及如何处理

Matching Bounds: How Choice of Matching Algorithm Impacts Treatment Effects Estimates and What to Do about It

Marco Morucci, Cynthia Rudin

摘要:

社会科学中的许多主要著作都采用匹配来得出因果关系的结论,但对同一数据进行不同的匹配可能会产生不同的处理效应估计,即使它们实现了类似的平衡或最小化了相同的损失函数。我们讨论了这个问题的原因和后果。我们目前的证据,这个问题,通过复制10篇论文,使用匹配,我们发现,不同的流行匹配算法产生不一致的结果。我们引入匹配边界:一种有限样本的非随机方法,允许分析人员知道是否可以从他们的数据中获得具有相同平衡水平和总体匹配质量的匹配样本,从而产生不同的结果。我们应用匹配边界复制两项研究,并表明,在一种情况下,结果是强大的这个问题,在另一个他们没有。

英文摘要:

Many major works in social science employ matching to make causal conclusions, but different matches on the same data may produce different treatment effect estimates, even when they achieve similar balance or minimize the same loss function. We discuss reasons and consequences of this problem. We present evidence of this problem by replicating ten papers that use matching and we find that different popular matching algorithms produce inconsistent results. We introduce Matching Bounds: a finite-sample, nonstochastic method that allows analysts to know whether a matched sample that produces different results with the same levels of balance and overall match quality could be obtained from their data. We apply Matching Bounds to a replication of two studies and show that in one case results are robust to this issue and in another they are not.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑