多项选择题中答案复习效应的部分识别
Partial Identification of Answer Reviewing Effects in Multiple-Choice Exams
摘要:
在选择题考试中复习以前的答案是否有助于考生提高最终分数?本文使用严格的因果框架,潜在结果框架,正式的问题。本文首先将考生的复习状态视为一种处理,将其最终成绩视为一种结果,解释了在常规考试环境中识别答案复习因果效应的挑战。除了无法随机选择治疗(审查状态)和缺乏其他信息使这一选择过程可验证之外,研究人员还不完全了解治疗变量本身。查看考生的答题卡数据,不清楚一名考生在特定项目上没有改变答案,但保留了最初的答案(处理条件),还是选择不复习(对照条件)。然而,尽管存在这些挑战,本文还是提出了部分识别策略,并表明答案复习效应的符号是可以合理推断的。通过对一个全国范围的数学评估数据集的分析,本文发现,审查初步答案一般是有益的考生。
英文摘要:
Does reviewing previous answers during multiple-choice exams help examinees increase their final score? This article formalizes the question using a rigorous causal framework, the potential outcomes framework. Viewing examinees' reviewing status as a treatment and their final score as an outcome, the article first explains the challenges of identifying the causal effect of answer reviewing in regular exam-taking settings. In addition to the incapability of randomizing the treatment selection (reviewing status) and the lack of other information to make this selection process ignorable, the treatment variable itself is not fully known to researchers. Looking at examinees' answer sheet data, it is unclear whether an examinee who did not change his or her answer on a specific item reviewed it but retained the initial answer (treatment condition) or chose not to review it (control condition). Despite such challenges, however, the article develops partial identification strategies and shows that the sign of the answer reviewing effect can be reasonably inferred. By analyzing a statewide math assessment data set, the article finds that reviewing initial answers is generally beneficial for examinees.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。