arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2008.04627cs.RO
收藏

人形机器人模拟器的定量比较

A Comparison of Humanoid Robot Simulators: A Quantitative Approach

Escola Politécnica de Pernambuco, Universidade de Pernambuco(伯南布哥大学伯南布哥理工学院);Escuela de Ingeniería, Universidad Central de Chile(智利中央大学工程学院);School of Information Technology, Deakin University(迪肯大学信息技术学院)

Angel Ayala, Francisco Cruz, Diego Campos, Rodrigo Rubio, Bruno Fernandes, Richard Dazeley

摘要:

人形机器人系统的研究涉及大量的计算资源,不仅涉及设计,而且其开发和随后的实施。对于在现实世界场景中实施的机器人系统,在几种情况下,最好在受控环境下开发和测试它们,以降低错误和意外行为的风险。在这方面,一个更容易获得和有效的替代方案是使用机器人模拟工具来实现环境。本文提出了一个定量比较的Gazebo,Webots和V-REP,三个模拟器广泛使用的研究界开发机器人系统。为了比较这三个模拟器的性能,使用CPU,内存占用和磁盘访问等元素来测量和比较它们。为了测量资源的使用,每个模拟器执行20次由NAO机器人组成的机器人场景,该机器人必须避开特定障碍物导航到目标位置。总的来说,我们的研究结果表明,Webots是资源使用率最低的模拟器,其次是V-REP,它比Gazebo更具优势,主要是因为CPU的使用。

英文摘要:

Research on humanoid robotic systems involves a considerable amount of computational resources, not only for the involved design but also for its development and subsequent implementation. For robotic systems to be implemented in real-world scenarios, in several situations, it is preferred to develop and test them under controlled environments in order to reduce the risk of errors and unexpected behavior. In this regard, a more accessible and efficient alternative is to implement the environment using robotic simulation tools. This paper presents a quantitative comparison of Gazebo, Webots, and V-REP, three simulators widely used by the research community to develop robotic systems. To compare the performance of these three simulators, elements such as CPU, memory footprint, and disk access are used to measure and compare them to each other. In order to measure the use of resources, each simulator executes 20 times a robotic scenario composed by a NAO robot that must navigate to a goal position avoiding a specific obstacle. In general terms, our results show that Webots is the simulator with the lowest use of resources, followed by V-REP, which has advantages over Gazebo, mainly because of the CPU use.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑