Tandem Assessment of Spoofing Countermeasures and Automatic Speaker Verification: Fundamentals
University of Eastern Finland（东芬兰大学）；Nuance Communications Inc.（纽安斯通信公司）；EURECOM（欧洲通信学院）；NEC Corporation（日本电气公司）；National Institute of Informatics（国立信息学研究所）；Université de Lorraine（洛林大学）；CNRS（法国国家科学研究中心）；Inria（法国国家信息与自动化研究所）；LORIA（洛林计算机科学与应用研究实验室）；MIT Lincoln Laboratory（麻省理工学院林肯实验室）
Tomi Kinnunen, Héctor Delgado, Nicholas Evans, Kong Aik Lee, Ville Vestman, Andreas Nautsch, Massimiliano Todisco, Xin Wang, Md Sahidullah, Junichi Yamagishi, Douglas A. Reynolds
备注：
Published in IEEE/ACM Transactions on Audio, Speech, and Language Processing (doi updated)
Recent years have seen growing efforts to develop spoofing countermeasures (CMs) to protect automatic speaker verification (ASV) systems from being deceived by manipulated or artificial inputs. The reliability of spoofing CMs is typically gauged using the equal error rate (EER) metric. The primitive EER fails to reflect application requirements and the impact of spoofing and CMs upon ASV and its use as a primary metric in traditional ASV research has long been abandoned in favour of risk-based approaches to assessment. This paper presents several new extensions to the tandem detection cost function (t-DCF), a recent risk-based approach to assess the reliability of spoofing CMs deployed in tandem with an ASV system. Extensions include a simplified version of the t-DCF with fewer parameters, an analysis of a special case for a fixed ASV system, simulations which give original insights into its interpretation and new analyses using the ASVspoof 2019 database. It is hoped that adoption of the t-DCF for the CM assessment will help to foster closer collaboration between the anti-spoofing and ASV research communities.
National Taiwan University（台湾大学）；The Chinese University of Hong Kong（香港中文大学）
Various forefront countermeasure methods for automatic speaker verification (ASV) with considerable performance in anti-spoofing are proposed in the ASVspoof 2019 challenge. However, previous work has shown that countermeasure models are vulnerable to adversarial examples indistinguishable from natural data. A good countermeasure model should not only be robust against spoofing audio, including synthetic, converted, and replayed audios; but counteract deliberately generated examples by malicious adversaries. In this work, we introduce a passive defense method, spatial smoothing, and a proactiv…
The automatic speaker verification spoofing and countermeasures (ASVspoof) challenge series is a community-led initiative which aims to promote the consideration of spoofing and the development of countermeasures. ASVspoof 2021 is the 4th in a series of bi-annual, competitive challenges where the goal is to develop countermeasures capable of discriminating between bona fide and spoofed or deepfake speech. This document provides a technical description of the ASVspoof 2021 challenge, including details of training, development and evaluation data, metrics, baselines, evaluation rules, submission…
University of Eastern Finland（东芬兰大学）；National University of Singapore（新加坡国立大学）；National Institute of Informatics（国立信息学研究所）
As automatic speaker verification (ASV) systems are vulnerable to spoofing attacks, they are typically used in conjunction with spoofing countermeasure (CM) systems to improve security. For example, the CM can first determine whether the input is human speech, then the ASV can determine whether this speech matches the speaker's identity. The performance of such a tandem system can be measured with a tandem detection cost function (t-DCF). However, ASV and CM systems are usually trained separately, using different metrics and data, which does not optimize their combined performance. In this wor…
This paper describes the NPU system submitted to Spoofing Aware Speaker Verification Challenge 2022. We particularly focus on the \textit{backend ensemble} for speaker verification and spoofing countermeasure from three aspects. Firstly, besides simple concatenation, we propose circulant matrix transformation and stacking for speaker embeddings and countermeasure embeddings. With the stacking operation of newly-defined circulant embeddings, we almost explore all the possible interactions between speaker embeddings and countermeasure embeddings. Secondly, we attempt different convolution neural…
Anti-spoofing for automatic speaker verification is now a well established area of research, with three competitive challenges having been held in the last 6 years. A great deal of research effort over this time has been invested into the development of front-end representations tailored to the spoofing detection task. One such approach known as constant Q cepstral coefficients (CQCCs) have been shown to be especially effective in detecting attacks implemented with a unit selection based speech synthesis algorithm. Despite their success, they largely fail in detecting other forms of spoofing a…
Many existing speaker verification systems are reported to be vulnerable against different spoofing attacks, for example speaker-adapted speech synthesis, voice conversion, play back, etc. In order to detect these spoofed speech signals as a countermeasure, we propose a score level fusion approach with several different i-vector subsystems. We show that the acoustic level Mel-frequency cepstral coefficients (MFCC) features, the phase level modified group delay cepstral coefficients (MGDCC) and the phonetic level phoneme posterior probability (PPP) tandem features are effective for the counterm…
National Institute of Informatics (NII)（日本国立信息学研究所）
The spoofing countermeasure (CM) systems in automatic speaker verification (ASV) are not typically used in isolation of each other. These systems can be combined, for example, into a cascaded system where CM produces first a decision whether the input is synthetic or bona fide speech. In case the CM decides it is a bona fide sample, then the ASV system will consider it for speaker verification. End users of the system are not interested in the performance of the individual sub-modules, but instead are interested in the performance of the combined system. Such combination can be evaluated with …
University of Eastern Finland（东芬兰大学）；NEC Corporation（日本电气股份有限公司）；EURECOM（欧洲通信学院）；Inria（法国国家信息与自动化研究所）；National Institute of Informatics（国立信息学研究所）；University of Edinburgh（爱丁堡大学）；MIT（麻省理工学院）
The ASVspoof challenge series was born to spearhead research in anti-spoofing for automatic speaker verification (ASV). The two challenge editions in 2015 and 2017 involved the assessment of spoofing countermeasures (CMs) in isolation from ASV using an equal error rate (EER) metric. While a strategic approach to assessment at the time, it has certain shortcomings. First, the CM EER is not necessarily a reliable predictor of performance when ASV and CMs are combined. Second, the EER operating point is ill-suited to user authentication applications, e.g. telephone banking, characterised by a hig…
Voice authentication has become an integral part in security-critical operations, such as bank transactions and call center conversations. The vulnerability of automatic speaker verification systems (ASVs) to spoofing attacks instigated the development of countermeasures (CMs), whose task is to tell apart bonafide and spoofed speech. Together, ASVs and CMs form today's voice authentication platforms, advertised as an impregnable access control mechanism. We develop the first practical attack on CMs, and show how a malicious actor may efficiently craft audio samples to bypass voice authenticati…
This paper presents the Speech Technology Center (STC) replay attack detection systems proposed for Automatic Speaker Verification Spoofing and Countermeasures Challenge 2017. In this study we focused on comparison of different spoofing detection approaches. These were GMM based methods, high level features extraction with simple classifier and deep learning frameworks. Experiments performed on the development and evaluation parts of the challenge dataset demonstrated stable efficiency of deep learning approaches in case of changing acoustic conditions. At the same time SVM classifier with hig…
National Institute of Informatics（国立信息学研究所）；University of Edinburgh（爱丁堡大学）；Inria（法国国家信息与自动化研究所）；University of Eastern Finland（东芬兰大学）
Automatic speaker verification (ASV) systems use a playback detector to filter out playback attacks and ensure verification reliability. Since current playback detection models are almost always trained using genuine and played-back speech, it may be possible to degrade their performance by transforming the acoustic characteristics of the played-back speech close to that of the genuine speech. One way to do this is to enhance speech "stolen" from the target speaker before playback. We tested the effectiveness of a playback attack using this method by using the speech enhancement generative adv…
Vanderbilt University（范德堡大学）；Vanderbilt University Medical Center（范德堡大学医学中心）
Research in the past several years has boosted the performance of automatic speaker verification systems and countermeasure systems to deliver low Equal Error Rates (EERs) on each system. However, research on joint optimization of both systems is still limited. The Spoofing-Aware Speaker Verification (SASV) 2022 challenge was proposed to encourage the development of integrated SASV systems with new metrics to evaluate joint model performance. This paper proposes an ensemble-free end-to-end solution, known as Spoof-Aggregated-SASV (SA-SASV) to build a SASV system with multi-task classifiers, wh…
University of Eastern Finland（东芬兰大学）；CNRS（法国国家科学研究中心）；Inria（法国国家信息与自动化研究所）；LORIA（洛林计算机科学与应用数学实验室）
In this paper, we initiate the concern of enhancing the spoofing robustness of the automatic speaker verification (ASV) system, without the primary presence of a separate countermeasure module. We start from the standard ASV framework of the ASVspoof 2019 baseline and approach the problem from the back-end classifier based on probabilistic linear discriminant analysis. We employ three unsupervised domain adaptation techniques to optimize the back-end using the audio data in the training partition of the ASVspoof 2019 dataset. We demonstrate notable improvements on both logical and physical acc…
The threat of spoofing can pose a risk to the reliability of automatic speaker verification. Results from the bi-annual ASVspoof evaluations show that effective countermeasures demand front-ends designed specifically for the detection of spoofing artefacts. Given the diversity in spoofing attacks, ensemble methods are particularly effective. The work in this paper shows that a bank of very simple classifiers, each with a front-end tuned to the detection of different spoofing attacks and combined at the score level through non-linear fusion, can deliver superior performance than more sophistica…
CPqD Foundation（CPqD基金会）；University of Campinas（坎皮纳斯州立大学）
It is well known that speaker verification systems are subject to spoofing attacks. The Automatic Speaker Verification Spoofing and Countermeasures Challenge -- ASVSpoof2015 -- provides a standard spoofing database, containing attacks based on synthetic speech, along with a protocol for experiments. This paper describes CPqD's systems submitted to the ASVSpoof2015 Challenge, based on deep neural networks, working both as a classifier and as a feature extraction module for a GMM and a SVM classifier. Results show the validity of this approach, achieving less than 0.5\% EER for known attacks.
National Taiwan University（国立台湾大学）；The Chinese University of Hong Kong（香港中文大学）；Tsinghua University（清华大学）
Recent years have witnessed the extraordinary development of automatic speaker verification (ASV). However, previous works show that state-of-the-art ASV models are seriously vulnerable to voice spoofing attacks, and the recently proposed high-performance spoofing countermeasure (CM) models only focus solely on the standalone anti-spoofing tasks, and ignore the subsequent speaker verification process. How to integrate the CM and ASV together remains an open question. A spoofing aware speaker verification (SASV) challenge has recently taken place with the argument that better performance can be…
ASV (automatic speaker verification) systems are intrinsically required to reject both non-target (e.g., voice uttered by different speaker) and spoofed (e.g., synthesised or converted) inputs. However, there is little consideration for how ASV systems themselves should be adapted when they are expected to encounter spoofing attacks, nor when they operate in tandem with CMs (spoofing countermeasures), much less how both systems should be jointly optimised. The goal of the first SASV (spoofing-aware speaker verification) challenge, a special sesscion in ISCA INTERSPEECH 2022, is to promote deve…
Spoofing attacks posed by generating artificial speech can severely degrade the performance of a speaker verification system. Recently, many anti-spoofing countermeasures have been proposed for detecting varying types of attacks from synthetic speech to replay presentations. While there are numerous effective defenses reported on standalone anti-spoofing solutions, the integration for speaker verification and spoofing detection systems has obvious benefits. In this paper, we propose a spoofing-robust automatic speaker verification (SR-ASV) system for diverse attacks based on a multi-task learn…
National Taiwan University（台湾大学）；The Chinese University of Hong Kong（香港中文大学）
Recently, many novel techniques have been introduced to deal with spoofing attacks, and achieve promising countermeasure (CM) performances. However, these works only take the stand-alone CM models into account. Nowadays, a spoofing aware speaker verification (SASV) challenge which aims to facilitate the research of integrated CM and ASV models, arguing that jointly optimizing CM and ASV models will lead to better performance, is taking place. In this paper, we propose a novel multi-model and multi-level fusion strategy to tackle the SASV task. Compared with purely scoring fusion and embedding …
Wuhan University（武汉大学）；Duke Kunshan University（昆山杜克大学）；Guangdong OPPO Mobile Telecommunications Corp., Ltd.（广东OPPO移动通信有限公司）
This paper describes our DKU-OPPO system for the 2022 Spoofing-Aware Speaker Verification (SASV) Challenge. First, we split the joint task into speaker verification (SV) and spoofing countermeasure (CM), these two tasks which are optimized separately. For ASV systems, four state-of-the-art methods are employed. For CM systems, we propose two methods on top of the challenge baseline to further improve the performance, namely Embedding Random Sampling Augmentation (ERSA) and One-Class Confusion Loss(OCCL). Second, we also explore whether SV embedding could help improve CM system performance. We …
EURECOM（欧洲电信学院）；National Institute of Informatics（国立信息学研究所）；Naver Corporation（Naver公司）
The performance of spoofing countermeasure systems depends fundamentally upon the use of sufficiently representative training data. With this usually being limited, current solutions typically lack generalisation to attacks encountered in the wild. Strategies to improve reliability in the face of uncontrolled, unpredictable attacks are hence needed. We report in this paper our efforts to use self-supervised learning in the form of a wav2vec 2.0 front-end with fine tuning. Despite initial base representations being learned using only bona fide data and no spoofed data, we obtain the lowest equa…
Queen Mary University of London（伦敦玛丽女王大学）；KTH Royal Institute of Engineering（KTH皇家理工学院）
Detecting spoofing attempts of automatic speaker verification (ASV) systems is challenging, especially when using only one modeling approach. For robustness, we use both deep neural networks and traditional machine learning models and combine them as ensemble models through logistic regression. They are trained to detect logical access (LA) and physical access (PA) attacks on the dataset released as part of the ASV Spoofing and Countermeasures Challenge 2019. We propose dataset partitions that ensure different attack types are present during training and validation to improve system robustness…
University of Seoul（首尔大学）；EURECOM（欧洲通信学院）；University of Eastern Finland（东芬兰大学）；Naver Corporation（Naver公司）；KAIST（韩国科学技术院）；Nuance Communications（纽昂斯通信公司）；Inria（法国国家信息与自动化研究所）
Deep learning has brought impressive progress in the study of both automatic speaker verification (ASV) and spoofing countermeasures (CM). Although solutions are mutually dependent, they have typically evolved as standalone sub-systems whereby CM solutions are usually designed for a fixed ASV system. The work reported in this paper aims to gauge the improvements in reliability that can be gained from their closer integration. Results derived using the popular ASVspoof2019 dataset indicate that the equal error rate (EER) of a state-of-the-art ASV system degrades from 1.63% to 23.83% when the ev…
Automatic speaker verification (ASV) systems utilize the biometric information in human speech to verify the speaker's identity. The techniques used for performing speaker verification are often vulnerable to malicious attacks that attempt to induce the ASV system to return wrong results, allowing an impostor to bypass the system and gain access. Attackers use a multitude of spoofing techniques for this, such as voice conversion, audio replay, speech synthesis, etc. In recent years, easily available tools to generate deepfaked audio have increased the potential threat to ASV systems. In this p…
Revisiting and Improving Scoring Fusion for Spoofing-aware Speaker Verification Using Compositional Data Analysis
National Institute of Informatics（信息学研究所）；University of Eastern Finland（东芬兰大学）；The Hong Kong Polytechnic University（香港理工大学）；Avignon Université（阿维尼翁大学）；Laboratoire Informatique d’Avignon（阿维尼翁计算机实验室）
Malicious actors may seek to use different voice-spoofing attacks to fool ASV systems and even use them for spreading misinformation. Various countermeasures have been proposed to detect these spoofing attacks. Due to the extensive work done on spoofing detection in automated speaker verification (ASV) systems in the last 6-7 years, there is a need to classify the research and perform qualitative and quantitative comparisons on state-of-the-art countermeasures. Additionally, no existing survey paper has reviewed integrated solutions to voice spoofing evaluation and speaker verification, advers…
Automatic Speaker Verification (ASV) system is a type of bio-metric authentication. It can be attacked by an intruder, who falsifies data in order to get access to protected information. Countermeasures (CM) are special algorithms that detect these spoofing-attacks. While the ASVspoof Challenge series were focused on the development of CM for fixed ASV system, the new Spoofing Aware Speaker Verification (SASV) Challenge organizers believe that best results can be achieved if CM and ASV systems are optimized jointly. One of the approaches for cooperative optimization is a fusion over embeddings…
This paper describes our DKU replay detection system for the ASVspoof 2019 challenge. The goal is to develop spoofing countermeasure for automatic speaker recognition in physical access scenario. We leverage the countermeasure system pipeline from four aspects, including the data augmentation, feature representation, classification, and fusion. First, we introduce an utterance-level deep learning framework for anti-spoofing. It receives the variable-length feature sequence and outputs the utterance-level scores directly. Based on the framework, we try out various kinds of input feature represe…
Computer Research Institute of Montreal (CRIM)（蒙特利尔计算机研究所（CRIM））
The main objective of the spoofing countermeasure system is to detect the artifacts within the input speech caused by the speech synthesis or voice conversion process. In order to achieve this, we propose to adopt an attentive activation function, more specifically attention rectified linear unit (AReLU) to the end-to-end spoofing countermeasure system. Since the AReLU employs the attention mechanism to boost the contribution of relevant input features while suppressing the irrelevant ones, introducing AReLU can help the countermeasure system to focus on the features related to the artifacts. …
University of Yamanashi（山梨大学）；Duke Kunshan University（昆山杜克大学）；Wuhan University（武汉大学）
A reliable voice anti-spoofing countermeasure system needs to robustly protect automatic speaker verification (ASV) systems in various kinds of spoofing scenarios. However, the performance of countermeasure systems could be degraded by channel effects and codecs. In this paper, we show that using the low-frequency subbands of signals as input can mitigate the negative impact introduced by codecs on the countermeasure systems. To validate this, two types of low-pass filters with different cut-off frequencies are applied to countermeasure systems, and the equal error rate (EER) is reduced by up …
The spoof speech detection (SSD) is the essential countermeasure for automatic speaker verification systems. Although SSD with magnitude features in the frequency domain has shown promising results, the phase information also can be important to capture the artefacts of certain types of spoofing attacks. Thus, both magnitude and phase features must be considered to ensure the generalization ability to diverse types of spoofing attacks. In this paper, we investigate the failure reason of feature-level fusion of the previous works through the entropy analysis from which we found that the randomn…
The Chinese University of Hong Kong（香港中文大学）；National Taiwan University（国立台湾大学）
High-performance spoofing countermeasure systems for automatic speaker verification (ASV) have been proposed in the ASVspoof 2019 challenge. However, the robustness of such systems under adversarial attacks has not been studied yet. In this paper, we investigate the vulnerability of spoofing countermeasures for ASV under both white-box and black-box adversarial attacks with the fast gradient sign method (FGSM) and the projected gradient descent (PGD) method. We implement high-performing countermeasure models in the ASVspoof 2019 challenge and conduct adversarial attacks on them. We compare per…
Automatic Speaker Verification (ASV) is the process of identifying a person based on the voice presented to a system. Different synthetic approaches allow spoofing to deceive ASV systems (ASVs), whether using techniques to imitate a voice or recunstruct the features. Attackers try to beat up the ASVs using four general techniques; impersonation, speech synthesis, voice conversion, and replay. The last technique is considered as a common and high potential tool for spoofing purposes since replay attacks are more accessible and require no technical knowledge from adversaries. In this study, we i…
Towards single integrated spoofing-aware speaker verification embeddings
Seoul National University（首尔国立大学）；University of Eastern Finland（东芬兰大学）；EURECOM（欧洲通信研究院）；National Institute of Informatics（国立信息学研究所）；Inria（法国国家信息与自动化研究所）；TCG CREST（TCG CREST研究中心）；Institute for Infocomm Research, A*STAR（新加坡科技研究局资讯通信研究院）；Carnegie Mellon University（卡内基梅隆大学）；Naver Corporation（Naver公司）
Enhancing Anti-spoofing Countermeasures Robustness through Joint Optimization and Transfer Learning
Integrated Graduate School of Medicine, Engineering, and Agricultural Sciences, University of Yamanashi（山梨大学医学、工学和农学综合研究生院）；Duke Kunshan University（昆山杜克大学）；School of Computer Science, Wuhan University（武汉大学计算机学院）
CompSpoof: A Dataset and Joint Learning Framework for Component-Level Audio Anti-spoofing Countermeasures
Suzhou Municipal Key Laboratory of Multimodal Intelligent Systems（多模态智能系统苏州市重点实验室）；Digital Innovation Research Center（数字创新研究中心）；Duke Kunshan University（杜克昆山大学）；OfSpectrum, Inc.（OfSpectrum公司）
Voice-based biometric systems are highly prone to spoofing attacks. Recently, various countermeasures have been developed for detecting different kinds of attacks such as replay, speech synthesis (SS) and voice conversion (VC). Most of the existing studies are conducted with a specific training set defined by the evaluation protocol. However, for realistic scenarios, selecting appropriate training data is an open challenge for the system administrator. Motivated by this practical concern, this work investigates the generalization capability of spoofing countermeasures in restricted training co…
A good training set for speech spoofing countermeasures requires diverse TTS and VC spoofing attacks, but generating TTS and VC spoofed trials for a target speaker may be technically demanding. Instead of using full-fledged TTS and VC systems, this study uses neural-network-based vocoders to do copy-synthesis on bona fide utterances. The output data can be used as spoofed data. To make better use of pairs of bona fide and spoofed data, this study introduces a contrastive feature loss that can be plugged into the standard training criterion. On the basis of the bona fide trials from the ASVspoo…
Conventional speech spoofing countermeasures (CMs) are designed to make a binary decision on an input trial. However, a CM trained on a closed-set database is theoretically not guaranteed to perform well on unknown spoofing attacks. In some scenarios, an alternative strategy is to let the CM defer a decision when it is not confident. The question is then how to estimate a CM's confidence regarding an input trial. We investigated a few confidence estimators that can be easily plugged into a CM. On the ASVspoof2019 logical access database, the results demonstrate that an energy-based estimator a…
Queen Mary University of London（伦敦玛丽女王大学）；KTH Royal Institute of Technology（瑞典皇家理工学院）
The Automatic Speaker Verification Spoofing and Countermeasures Challenges motivate research in protecting speech biometric systems against a variety of different access attacks. The 2017 edition focused on replay spoofing attacks, and involved participants building and training systems on a provided dataset (ASVspoof 2017). More than 60 research papers have so far been published with this dataset, but none have sought to answer why countermeasures appear successful in detecting spoofing attacks. This article shows how artefacts inherent to the dataset may be contributing to the apparent succe…
A great deal of recent research effort on speech spoofing countermeasures has been invested into back-end neural networks and training criteria. We contribute to this effort with a comparative perspective in this study. Our comparison of countermeasure models on the ASVspoof 2019 logical access task takes into account recently proposed margin-based training criteria, widely used front ends, and common strategies to deal with varied-length input trials. We also measured intra-model differences through multiple training-evaluation rounds with random initialization. Our statistical analysis demon…
Self-supervised speech model is a rapid progressing research topic, and many pre-trained models have been released and used in various down stream tasks. For speech anti-spoofing, most countermeasures (CMs) use signal processing algorithms to extract acoustic features for classification. In this study, we use pre-trained self-supervised speech models as the front end of spoofing CMs. We investigated different back end architectures to be combined with the self-supervised front end, the effectiveness of fine-tuning the front end, and the performance of using different pre-trained self-supervise…
Spoofing countermeasures aim to protect automatic speaker verification systems from attempts to manipulate their reliability with the use of spoofed speech signals. While results from the most recent ASVspoof 2019 evaluation show great potential to detect most forms of attack, some continue to evade detection. This paper reports the first application of RawNet2 to anti-spoofing. RawNet2 ingests raw audio and has potential to learn cues that are not detectable using more traditional countermeasure solutions. We describe modifications made to the original RawNet2 architecture so that it can be a…
Johns Hopkins University（约翰斯·霍普金斯大学）；University of Edinburgh（爱丁堡大学）；University of Lisbon（里斯本大学）；INESC-ID（葡萄牙系统与计算机工程研究所 - 里斯本分院）；National Institute of Informatics（国立信息学研究所）
An attacker may use a variety of techniques to fool an automatic speaker verification system into accepting them as a genuine user. Anti-spoofing methods meanwhile aim to make the system robust against such attacks. The ASVspoof 2017 Challenge focused specifically on replay attacks, with the intention of measuring the limits of replay attack detection as well as developing countermeasures against them. In this work, we propose our replay attacks detection system - Attentive Filtering Network, which is composed of an attention-based filtering mechanism that enhances feature representations in b…
An Intervention-Based Framework for Shortcut Diagnosis in Spoofing Countermeasures
University of ZaragozaSpain（萨拉戈塔大学西班牙）；Business Telecommunications ServicesSpain（业务电信服务西班牙）；ViVoLab, Aragón Institute for Engineering Research (I3A)（ViVoLab，阿拉贡工程研究院（I3A））
