可观察性是否增强了对道德框架的敏感性?评价基于声誉的道德偏好
Does observability amplify sensitivity to moral frames? Evaluating a reputation-based account of moral preferences
摘要:
越来越多的研究表明,在涉及亲社会性的经济游戏中,人们对道德框架很敏感,这表明人们对做“正确的事情”有道德偏好。是什么导致了这些偏好?在这里,我们评估的解释能力的声誉为基础的帐户,它提出,人们对道德框架的反应,因为他们的动机是看起来很好,在别人的眼睛。在两个预先注册的实验(总N = 3,610)中,我们研究了声誉激励是否会放大对框架效应的敏感性。两个实验都操纵了(i)道德或中性框架是否被用来描述权衡游戏(参与者在优先考虑平等或效率之间进行选择)以及(ii)权衡游戏选择是否在随后的信任游戏中被社会伙伴观察到。我们发现,框架效应是相对不敏感的声誉激励:可观察性并没有显着放大敏感性的道德框架。然而,我们的研究结果并不与可观察性具有一定放大效应的可能性相矛盾;定量地说,当决策是私人的时,观察到的框架效应是可观察的时的74%。这些结果表明,道德框架可能会利用道德偏好,是相对较深的内在化,和道德框架的力量,以促进亲社会性可能不会强烈增强,使道德框架的行为观察到他人。
英文摘要:
A growing body of work suggests that people are sensitive to moral framing in economic games involving prosociality, suggesting that people hold moral preferences for doing the "right thing". What gives rise to these preferences? Here, we evaluate the explanatory power of a reputation-based account, which proposes that people respond to moral frames because they are motivated to look good in the eyes of others. Across two pre-registered experiments (total N = 3,610), we investigated whether reputational incentives amplify sensitivity to framing effects. Both experiments manipulated (i) whether moral or neutral framing was used to describe a Trade-Off Game (in which participants chose between prioritizing equality or efficiency) and (ii) whether Trade-Off Game choices were observable to a social partner in a subsequent Trust Game. We find that framing effects are relatively insensitive to reputational incentives: observability did not significantly amplify sensitivity to moral framing. However, our results are not inconsistent with the possibility that observability has some amplification effect; quantitatively, the observed framing effect was 74% as large when decisions were private as when they were observable. These results suggest that moral frames may tap into moral preferences that are relatively deeply internalized, and that power of moral frames to promote prosociality may not be strongly enhanced by making the morally-framed behavior observable to others.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。