将修正模块分析法扩展到包括正确反应:对力量概念量表的分析
Extending Modified Module Analysis to Include Correct Responses: An Analysis of the Force Concept Inventory
摘要:
Brewe,Bruun和Bearden首先应用网络分析来理解多项选择工具中不正确的概念物理推理模式,并引入了多项选择响应模块分析(MAMCR)算法。Wells { \it等}提出了一个扩展的算法,允许分析大型数据集称为修改模块分析(MMA)。该方法分析了多项选择题回答的相关矩阵的网络结构。MAMCR和MMA都只能应用于不正确反应的网络。在这项研究中,MMA的扩展进行了探讨,它允许网络分析涉及正确和不正确的反应。该扩展分析了部分相关矩阵的网络结构,而不是相关矩阵。新的算法,称为MMA-P,被应用到FCI和恢复MMA确定的大部分结构。该算法还确定了正确的答案集,需要类似的物理推理在以前的研究报告。除了所有正确和所有不正确的反应组之外,还确定了一些混合正确和不正确反应的反应组。其中一些混合回答组是在出于不正确的原因选择了正确的回答时产生的;其中一些组有助于解释以前为FCI报告的性别不公平现象。
英文摘要:
Brewe, Bruun, and Bearden first applied network analysis to understand patterns of incorrect conceptual physics reasoning in multiple-choice instruments introducing the Module Analysis for Multiple-Choice Responses (MAMCR) algorithm. Wells {\it et al.} proposed an extension to the algorithm which allowed the analysis of large datasets called Modified Module Analysis (MMA). This method analyzed the network structure of the correlation matrix of the responses to a multiple-choice instrument. Both MAMCR and MMA could only be applied to networks of incorrect responses. In this study, an extension of MMA is explored which allows the analysis of networks involving both correct and incorrect responses. The extension analyzes the network structure of the partial correlation matrix instead of the correlation matrix. The new algorithm, called MMA-P, was applied to the FCI and recovered much of the structure identified by MMA. The algorithm also identified sets of correct answers requiring similar physical reasoning reported in previous studies. Beyond groups of all correct and all incorrect responses, some groups of responses which mixed correct and incorrect responses were also identified. Some of these mixed response groups were produced when a correct response was selected for incorrect reasons; some of the groups helped to explain the gender unfairness previously reported for the FCI.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。