arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1910.03466cs.LGcs.AIstat.ML
收藏

我们能区分机器学习和人类学习吗?

Can We Distinguish Machine Learning from Human Learning?

University of Wisconsin, Madison(威斯康星大学麦迪逊分校)

Vicki Bier, Paul B. Kantor, Gary Lupyan, Xiaojin Zhu

摘要:

是什么让一项任务对机器来说比对人类来说更难或更难?许多AI/ML研究都集中在扩大机器可以完成的任务范围上,重点是机器是否可以击败人类。考虑到规模的差异,我们可以寻找有趣的(异常的)任务对T,T '。我们以这种方式定义有趣:当将人类智能(HI)与AI进行比较时,“更难学习”的关系是颠倒的。虽然人类似乎能够通过制定规则来理解问题,但使用神经网络的ML并不依赖于构建规则。我们讨论了一种新的方法,其中的挑战是“在人类创造的规则下表现良好。“我们认为,这为理解这两种学习之间的差异提供了一条严格而精确的途径。具体来说,我们建议一个大的和可扩展的学习任务,制定为学习规则。通过这些任务,AI和HI都将被严格和精确地研究。直接目标是找到有趣的groundtruth规则对。从长远来看,我们的目标将是以一种可推广的方式理解有趣对与普通对的区别,并定义有趣对背后的显着性。这可能会为人工智能开辟新的思维方式,并为人类学习提供意想不到的见解。

英文摘要:

What makes a task relatively more or less difficult for a machine compared to a human? Much AI/ML research has focused on expanding the range of tasks that machines can do, with a focus on whether machines can beat humans. Allowing for differences in scale, we can seek interesting (anomalous) pairs of tasks T, T'. We define interesting in this way: The "harder to learn" relation is reversed when comparing human intelligence (HI) to AI. While humans seems to be able to understand problems by formulating rules, ML using neural networks does not rely on constructing rules. We discuss a novel approach where the challenge is to "perform well under rules that have been created by human beings." We suggest that this provides a rigorous and precise pathway for understanding the difference between the two kinds of learning. Specifically, we suggest a large and extensible class of learning tasks, formulated as learning under rules. With these tasks, both the AI and HI will be studied with rigor and precision. The immediate goal is to find interesting groundtruth rule pairs. In the long term, the goal will be to understand, in a generalizable way, what distinguishes interesting pairs from ordinary pairs, and to define saliency behind interesting pairs. This may open new ways of thinking about AI, and provide unexpected insights into human learning.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑