arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1909.09351cs.HCcs.GR
收藏

类地图可视化与树图可视化的实验比较

An Experimental Comparison of Map-like Visualisations and Treemaps

Patrick Cheong-Iao Pang, Robert P. Biuk-Aghai, Simon Fong, Yain-Whar Si

摘要:

树图已经在信息可视化中使用了二十多年。它们利用嵌套填充区域来表示信息层次结构,如文件系统、图书馆目录等。近年来,出现了类似于地理地图的可视化。在本文中,我们提出了一项研究,比较这样的一个类似地图的可视化与原始的两种形式的树图,即嵌套和非嵌套的树图的性能。我们的研究采用了一种混合方法来评估准确性,速度和可用性(例如易于使用和理解信息的帮助)。我们发现,准确性是最高的地图一样的可视化,其次是嵌套的树图,最后非嵌套的树图。嵌套树图的任务性能最快,其次是非嵌套树图,然后是类似地图的可视化。对于可用性,嵌套的树图被认为比类似地图的可视化稍微更有帮助,而非嵌套的表现不佳。我们的结论是,关于准确性的结果是有希望的使用地图般的可视化任务,涉及可视化的层次信息,而非嵌套的树图有利于在需要速度的任务。

英文摘要:

Treemaps have been used in information visualisation for over two decades. They make use of nested filled areas to represent information hierarchies such as file systems, library catalogues, etc. Recent years have witnessed the emergence of visualisations that resemble geographic maps. In this paper we present a study that compares the performance of one such map-like visualisation with the original two forms of the treemap, namely nested and non-nested treemaps. Our study employed a mixed-method evaluation of accuracy, speed and usability (such as the ease-of-use and helpfulness of understanding the information). We found that accuracy was highest for the map-like visualisations, followed by nested treemaps and lastly non-nested treemaps. Task performance was fastest for nested treemaps, followed by non-nested treemaps, and then map-like visualisations. For usability, nested treemaps was considered slightly more helpful than map-like visualisations while non-nested performed poorly. We conclude that the results regarding accuracy are promising for the use of map-like visualisations in tasks involving the visualisation of hierarchical information, while non-nested treemap are favoured in tasks requiring speed.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑