信息级联中的信息失真
Message Distortion in Information Cascades
摘要:
信息扩散通常被建模为不可变的信息片段在网络上传播的过程。然而,在现实中,消息并不是不可变的,而是可能随着每一步而变化,这可能会导致大量的累积失真。即使没有恶意行为者,这一过程也可能导致错误信息,理解这一点对于建模和改进在线信息系统至关重要。在这里,我们进行了一个受控的众包实验,在这个实验中,我们模拟了医学研究论文中信息的传播。从原始摘要开始,群组工作人员迭代地将先前生成的摘要缩短到越来越小的长度。我们还收集控制摘要,其中原始摘要被直接压缩到最终目标长度。将级联与控制进行比较,可以将长度约束的影响与累积失真的影响分开。通过仔细的手工编码,我们注释医学摘要中的词汇和语义单元,并沿着级联跟踪它们。我们发现,迭代摘要有一个负面的影响,由于积累的错误,但高质量的中间摘要导致失真的消息比在控制情况下。不同类型的信息表现不同;特别是医学摘要的结论(即,它的关键信息)是最扭曲的。最后,我们比较了抽象摘要和提取摘要,发现后者不太容易发生语义扭曲。总的来说,这项工作是研究信息级联的第一步,而不假设传播的内容是不可变的,对我们理解口碑效应对科学误报的作用有影响。
英文摘要:
Information diffusion is usually modeled as a process in which immutable pieces of information propagate over a network. In reality, however, messages are not immutable, but may be morphed with every step, potentially entailing large cumulative distortions. This process may lead to misinformation even in the absence of malevolent actors, and understanding it is crucial for modeling and improving online information systems. Here, we perform a controlled, crowdsourced experiment in which we simulate the propagation of information from medical research papers. Starting from the original abstracts, crowd workers iteratively shorten previously produced summaries to increasingly smaller lengths. We also collect control summaries where the original abstract is compressed directly to the final target length. Comparing cascades to controls allows us to separate the effect of the length constraint from that of accumulated distortion. Via careful manual coding, we annotate lexical and semantic units in the medical abstracts and track them along cascades. We find that iterative summarization has a negative impact due to the accumulation of error, but that high-quality intermediate summaries result in less distorted messages than in the control case. Different types of information behave differently; in particular, the conclusion of a medical abstract (i.e., its key message) is distorted most. Finally, we compare abstractive with extractive summaries, finding that the latter are less prone to semantic distortion. Overall, this work is a first step in studying information cascades without the assumption that disseminated content is immutable, with implications on our understanding of the role of word-of-mouth effects on the misreporting of science.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。