数字机构中的参与和变革设计
Designing for Participation and Change in Digital Institutions
摘要:
无论我们是否认识到这一点,互联网充满了令人兴奋的和原始的制度形式,这些形式正在改变在线和离线的社会组织。这些互联网平台和其他数字机构的治理问题对软件工程师构成了挑战,他们中的许多人几乎没有接触过相关的历史或制度设计理论。在这里,我们提供了一个有用的框架,旨在促进计算机科学家和政治科学家之间的对话。迄今为止,在人机交互、计算机支持的协同工作和整个技术行业中,数字机构设计的主导指导实践一直是以激励为中心的行为工程范式,一系列非理论方法,如A/B测试和增量问题驱动的软件工程。在传统制度的设计中有用的一个制度分析框架是被称为“奥斯特罗姆研讨会”的资源治理文献。这一文献的一个关键发现,尚未被广泛纳入许多数字机构的设计是包括参与性的变化过程机制的重要性,在所谓的“宪法层”的制度设计-换句话说,定义规则,允许和促进不同的利益相关者参与正在进行的过程中的制度设计变化。我们将探讨在三种不同的数字机构案例中,这种考虑在多大程度上得到了满足或可以得到更好的满足:加密货币、大麻信息学和业余Minecraft服务器治理。研究这些高度不同的案例使我们能够证明宪法层面在许多不同类型的数字机构中的广泛相关性。
英文摘要:
Whether we recognize it or not, the Internet is rife with exciting and original institutional forms that are transforming social organization on and offline. Issues of governance in these Internet platforms and other digital institutions have posed a challenge for software engineers, many of whom have little exposure to the relevant history or theory of institutional design. Here, we offer one useful framework with an aim to stimulate dialogue between computer scientists and political scientists. The dominant guiding practices for the design of digital institutions to date in human-computer interaction, computer-supported cooperative work, and the tech industry at large have been an incentive-focused behavioral engineering paradigm, a collection of atheoretical approaches such as A/B-testing, and incremental issue-driven software engineering. One institutional analysis framework that has been useful in the design of traditional institutions is the body of resource governance literature known as the "Ostrom Workshop". A key finding of this literature that has yet to be broadly incorporated in the design of many digital institutions is the importance of including participatory change process mechanisms in what is called a "constitutional layer" of institutional design---in other words, defining rules that allow and facilitate diverse stakeholder participation in the ongoing process of institutional design change. We explore to what extent this consideration is met or could be better met in three varied cases of digital institutions: cryptocurrencies, cannabis informatics, and amateur Minecraft server governance. Examining such highly varied cases allows us to demonstrate the broad relevance of constitutional layers in many different types of digital institutions.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。