arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1807.01595astro-ph.IM
收藏

Lomb-Scargle周期图与经典周期图的比较

A critical comparison of the Lomb-Scargle and the classical periodograms

R. Vio, P. Andreani

摘要:

探测隐藏在噪声中的信号是天文学中最古老和常见的问题之一。在过去已经提出了各种解决方案,如基于理论模板的最小二乘拟合的参数方法或相位折叠方法的非参数技术。然而,它们中的大多数仅适用于具有特定时间演化的信号。对于一般信号,基于周期图的谱方法可能是最有效的。在天文学中,使用周期图的主要问题是信号的采样往往是不规则的。这使其有效计算复杂化(不能直接使用快速傅立叶变换),但总体上使其统计特性的确定复杂化。Lomb-Scargle周期图(LSP)为这最后一个重要问题提供了解决方案,但其主要缺点是假设了一个非常特定的数据模型,这对于大多数实际应用来说是不正确的。这些问题并不总是被认为是在文学与理论和实践的后果,没有容易的解决方案。此外,除了病理取样,通常认为LSP和经典周期图(CP)通常提供几乎相同的结果。一般来说,这是真的,但这里示出了存在LSP在噪声中检测信号时不如CP有效的情况。因此,没有令人信服的理由使用LSP代替CP,CP直接连接到观察信号的关联函数与在各种感兴趣频率处的正弦函数。

英文摘要:

The detection of signals hidden in noise is one of the oldest and common problems in astronomy. Various solutions have been proposed in the past such as the parametric approaches based on the least-squares fit of theoretical templates or the non-parametric techniques as the phase-folding method. Most of them, however, are suited only for signals with specific time evolution. For generic signals the spectral approach based on the periodogram is potentially the most effective. In astronomy the main problem in working with the periodogram is that often the sampling of the signals is irregular. This complicates its efficient computation (the fast Fourier transform cannot be directly used) but overall the determination of its statistical characteristics. The Lomb-Scargle periodogram (LSP) provides a solution to this last important issue, but its main drawback is the assumption of a very specific model of the datawhich is not correct for most of the practical applications. These issues are not always considered in literature with theoretical and practical consequences of no easy solution. Moreover, apart from pathological samplings, it is common believe that the LSP and the classical periodogram (CP) usually provide almost identical results. In general, this is true but here it is shown that there are situations where the LSP is less effective than the CP in the detection of signals in noise. There are no compelling reasons, therefore, to use the LSP instead of the CP which is directly connected to the correlation function of the observed signal with the sinusoidal functions at the various frequencies of interest.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑