足球点球大战设计的比较
A comparison of penalty shootout designs in soccer
摘要:
足球比赛中的点球大战被认为是不公平的,因为在所有回合中先开球的球队享有明显的优势。最近有人提出所谓的追赶规则来解决这个问题,但这里所示的并不比已经尝试过的更简单的确定性交替(ABBA)规则更公平。我们引入了调整后的追赶规则,通过保证在第一轮中处于劣势的球队获得可能的突然死亡阶段的第一次处罚。它优于追赶和交替规则,同时仍然简单地实现。点球大战机制的复杂性的一般措施,也提供了在一个给定的回合,而不知道历史的点球大战决定先发所需的二元问题的最小数量。这种量化允许在未来提出的任何机制的二维评估。
英文摘要:
Penalty shootout in soccer is recognized to be unfair because the team kicking first in all rounds enjoys a significant advantage. The so-called Catch-Up Rule has been suggested recently to solve this problem but is shown here not to be fairer than the simpler deterministic Alternating (ABBA) Rule that has already been tried. We introduce the Adjusted Catch-Up Rule by guaranteeing the first penalty of the possible sudden death stage to the team disadvantaged in the first round. It outperforms the Catch-Up and Alternating Rules, while remains straightforward to implement. A general measure of complexity for penalty shootout mechanisms is also provided as the minimal number of binary questions required to decide the first-mover in a given round without knowing the history of the penalty shootout. This quantification permits a two-dimensional evaluation of any mechanism proposed in the future.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。