绝对与关系之争:现代全球版本
Absolute versus Relational Debate: a Modern Global Version
摘要:
假设一个人试图从一个对称的绝对空间中解放出来,方法是导出它的对称群。然而,这通常无法抹去关于绝对空间对称性的所有记忆。分层是造成这种情况的一个主要原因,它存在于a)肯德尔型形状理论和随后的关系力学,以及b)广义相对论配置空间中。我们考虑另一个起点与一般的绝对空间,这意味着没有任何非平凡的广义Killing向量。在这种方法中,一般来说,形状和规模理论只是平凡地实现,没有单独的形状理论,实际上也没有分层。虽然这些考虑的GR位形空间版本已经在1996年由Fischer和Moncrief阐述,但肯德尔型形状理论版本对本文来说是新的。在每一种情况下,这相当于承认一些小的变形,对称性的硬后果的水平上减少配置spaces.We结束时讨论的意义上,其中每一个上述两种策略保留绝对主义的功能,每个已知的主要技术优势和缺点,以及可取的地方和近似形状理论取代肯德尔型形状理论。这篇文章是为了纪念Niall ó Murchadha教授,在他的论文发表之际。
英文摘要:
Suppose one seeks to free oneself from a symmetric absolute space by quotienting out its symmetry group. This in general however fails to erase all memory of this absolute space's symmetry properties. Stratification is one major reason for this, which is present in both a) Kendall-type Shape Theory and subsequent Relational Mechanics, and b) General Relativity configuration spaces. We consider the alternative starting point with a generic absolute space, meaning with no nontrivial generalized Killing vectors whatsoever. In this approach, generically Shape-and-Scale Theory is but trivially realized, there is no separate Shape Theory and indeed no stratification. While the GR configuration space version of these considerations was already expounded in 1996 by Fischer and Moncrief, the Kendall-type shape theory version is new to the current article. In each case, this amounts to admitting some small deformation by which symmetry's hard consequences at the level of reduced configuration spaces are warded off.We end by discussing the senses in which each of the above two strategies retain absolutist features, each's main known technical advantages and disadvantages, and the desirability of replacing Kendall-type Shape Theory with a Local-and-Approximate Shape Theory. This article is in honour of Prof. Niall ó Murchadha, on the occasion of his Festschrift.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。