词义稳定性与词替换率的关系:一项实验性检验
Stability of meanings versus rate of replacement of words: an experimental test
摘要:
一种语言中的单词会随着时间的推移被新的单词随机替换,但人们早就知道,与某些项目(含义)相对应的单词比其他项目(含义)更不频繁地被替换。通常,一个给定项目的替代率是不能直接观察到的,但它是由估计的稳定性推断出来的,相反,是可以观察到的。这个想法在词汇统计学文献中可以追溯到很久以前,然而没有任何东西能确保它给出正确的答案。罗曼语系允许直接测试估计的稳定性对替代率,因为原始语言(拉丁语)是已知的,替代率可以显式计算。测试的输出是三重的:首先,我们证明了标准的方法,试图推断的替代率通过估计的稳定性是健全的;第二,我们能够重写的基本公式的Glottochronology的非通用的替代率(率取决于项目);第三,我们给出了无可争辩的证据,稳定性排名是远远不是不同的语言家庭是相同的。最后一个结果也通过与马达加斯加语方言族的比较得到了支持。作为一个附带的结果,我们也提供了一些证据,通俗拉丁语,而不是晚期古典拉丁语是现代罗曼语的根源。
英文摘要:
The words of a language are randomly replaced in time by new ones, but it has long been known that words corresponding to some items (meanings) are less frequently replaced than others. Usually, the rate of replacement for a given item is not directly observable, but it is inferred by the estimated stability which, on the contrary, is observable. This idea goes back a long way in the lexicostatistical literature, nevertheless nothing ensures that it gives the correct answer. The family of Romance languages allows for a direct test of the estimated stabilities against the replacement rates since the proto-language (Latin) is known and the replacement rates can be explicitly computed. The output of the test is threefold:first, we prove that the standard approach which tries to infer the replacement rates trough the estimated stabilities is sound; second, we are able to rewrite the fundamental formula of Glottochronology for a non universal replacement rate (a rate which depends on the item); third, we give indisputable evidence that the stability ranking is far from being the same for different families of languages. This last result is also supported by comparison with the Malagasy family of dialects. As a side result we also provide some evidence that Vulgar Latin and not Late Classical Latin is at the root of modern Romance languages.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。