arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1712.09696physics.soc-ph
收藏

关于US最高法院的强烈共识跨越一个世纪

Strong consensus on US Supreme Court spans a century

Edward D. Lee

摘要:

在整个20世纪,美国最高法院一直被描述为自由派和保守派之间的分歧,这表明具有相似意识形态的法官如果任期重叠,他们会投类似的票。如果他们有呢?我用成对最大熵建立了一个实证的、定量的模型来解释这个反事实的假设。我推断1946年至2016年的36名大法官将如何投票决定超级最高法院。该模型与政治学中的标准投票模型惊人地一致,尽管使用了更少的参数,并且更好地拟合了观察到的统计数据。与历史上的法院一样,最高法院由共识主导。随着大法官人数的增加,共识的衰减速度非常缓慢,将近100年,这表明现代最高法院是一个非常稳定的机构。除了共识,我发现了一个丰富的结构,沿着重尾齐普夫定律分布的不同阵营。厚尾意味着占主导地位的异议模式未能捕捉到异议的整个光谱。因此,我发现,随着时间的推移,最高法院的投票并不是低维的,尽管在最高法院投票的历史分析中有相反的含义。虽然长期以来一直假设,强高阶相关性引起的情况下,机构和法官的功能,我表明,这种复杂性可以表示在一个极小模型只依赖于成对的相关性。从模型选择的角度来看,这种极小模型可以更好地推广,从而有助于预测最高法院投票随着时间的推移。

英文摘要:

The US Supreme Court throughout the 20th century has been characterized as being divided between liberals and conservatives, suggesting that justices with similar ideologies would have voted similarly had they overlapped in tenure. What if they had? I build an empirical, quantitative model of this counterfactual hypothesis using pairwise maximum entropy. I infer how 36 justices from 1946-2016 would have all voted on a Super Supreme Court. The model is strikingly consistent with a standard voting model from political science despite using $10^5$ less parameters and fitting the observed statistics better. As with historical courts, the Super Court is dominated by consensus. The rate at which consensus decays as more justices are included is extremely slow, nearly 100 years, and indicates that the modern Supreme Court is an extremely stable institution. Beyond consensus, I discover a rich structure of dissenting blocs that are distributed along a heavy-tailed Zipf's law. The heavy tail means that dominant dissenting modes fail to capture the entire spectrum of dissent. Thus, I find that Supreme Court voting over time is not low-dimensional despite implications to the contrary in historical analysis of Supreme Court voting. Although it has been long presumed that strong higher order correlations are induced by features of the cases, the institution, and the justices, I show that such complexity can be expressed in a minimal model relying only on pairwise correlations. From the perspective of model selection, this minimal model may generalize better and thus be useful for prediction of Supreme Court voting over time.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑