arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1709.08776stat.AP
收藏

忽略模型结构不确定性低估洪水灾害的上尾

Neglecting Model Structural Uncertainty Underestimates Upper Tails of Flood Hazard

Tony E. Wong, Alexandra Klufas, Vivek Srikrishnan, Klaus Keller

摘要:

沿海洪水给许多社区带来了相当大的风险,但对未来洪水风险的预测仍存在很大的不确定性。极端事件观测的缺乏往往促使人们使用统计方法来模拟极端风暴潮事件的分布。经常被忽视的一个关键的深度不确定性是模型结构不确定性。目前,专家们对于使用哪一类统计模型作为最佳做法没有达成强烈的共识。沿海洪水风险的稳健管理要求沿海管理人员考虑风暴潮非平稳性的明显可能性。这增加了要使用的潜在模型的复杂性,这往往会增加约束模型所需的数据。在这里,我们使用贝叶斯模型平均方法来分析模型复杂性(足以捕获决策相关风险)与数据可用性(以约束复杂模型结构)之间的平衡。我们通过一组校准实验来表征深层模型结构的不确定性。具体来说,我们校准一组模型的复杂性,使用长期的验潮观测从荷兰和美国。我们发现,在这两种情况下,大约一半的模型权重与非平稳模型相关。我们的方法提供了一个正式的框架,整合信息的模型结构,在潜在的相当大的建模不确定性。通过结合来自多个模型的信息,我们的推断为预计的风暴潮100年回报水平锐化,估计回报水平增加了几厘米。我们通过一组实验与时间子集和模型比较指标的数据可用性的影响进行评估。我们的分析表明,对于这里考虑的地点和方法,需要大约70年的数据来稳定100年回报水平的估计。

英文摘要:

Coastal flooding drives considerable risks to many communities, but projections of future flood risks are deeply uncertain. The paucity of observations of extreme events often motivates the use of statistical approaches to model the distribution of extreme storm surge events. A key deep uncertainty that is often overlooked is model structural uncertainty. There is currently no strong consensus among experts regarding which class of statistical model to use as a best practice. Robust management of coastal flooding risks requires coastal managers to consider the distinct possibility of non-stationarity in storm surges. This increases the complexity of the potential models to use, which tends to increase the data required to constrain the model. Here, we use a Bayesian model averaging approach to analyze the balance between model complexity sufficient to capture decision-relevant risks and data availability to constrain complex model structures. We characterize deep model structural uncertainty through a set of calibration experiments. Specifically, we calibrate a set of models ranging in complexity using long-term tide gauge observations from the Netherlands and the United States. We find that in both cases, roughly half the model weight is associated with non-stationary models. Our approach provides a formal framework to integrate information across model structures, in light of the potentially sizable modeling uncertainties. By combining information from multiple models, our inference sharpens for the projected storm surge 100-year return levels, and estimated return levels increase by several centimeters. We assess the impacts of data availability through a set of experiments with temporal subsets and model comparison metrics. Our analysis suggests about 70 years of data are required to stabilize estimates of the 100-year return level, for the locations and methods considered here.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑