为什么标量-张量等价理论在物理上不等价?
Why scalar-tensor equivalent theories are not physically equivalent?
摘要:
乔丹和爱因斯坦对F(R)引力理论的框架描述在物理上是否等价,是一个长期存在的争论。然而,实际上没有人质疑真正的数学等价性,因为经典的场方程可以从一个坐标系转换到另一个坐标系。在这里,我们表明,无论是诺特对称性,诺特方程,也可以量子方程可以从一个转换到另一个。原因是,保角变换导致了一个完全不同的系统,具有不同的拉格朗日量。场方程匹配仅仅是因为存在双态不变性。除非找到一个包含Hamilton约束方程的对称生成元,否则两个框架之间的数学等价性似乎是脆弱的。在任何情况下,在量子领域数学和物理等价性都不能成立。
英文摘要:
Whether Jordan's and Einstein's frame descriptions of F(R) theory of gravity are physically equivalent, is a long standing debate. However, practically none questioned on true mathematical equivalence, since classical field equations may be translated from one frame to the other following a transformation relation. Here we show that neither Noether symmetries, Noether equations, nor may quantum equations be translated from one to the other. The reason being, - conformal transformation results in a completely different system, with a different Lagrangian. Field equations match only due to the presence of diffeomorphic invariance. Unless a symmetry generator is found which involves Hamiltonian constraint equation, the mathematical equivalence between the two frames appears to be vulnerable. In any case, in quantum domain Mathematical and therefore physical equivalence can't be established.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。