arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1412.3518cs.AI
收藏

适当的因果模型与因果关系的稳定性

Appropriate Causal Models and the Stability of Causation

Cornell University(康奈尔大学)

Joseph Y. Halpern

摘要:

根据结构方程定义的因果模型已被证明是表示因果关系知识的一种非常强大的方式。然而,一些作者给出的例子似乎表明,Halpern-Pearl(HP)因果关系的定义给出了直观上不合理的答案。在这里,我们可以看到,对于每一个例子,我们可以给出两个与例子中的描述一致的故事,这样,关于因果关系的直觉对于每个故事都是完全不同的。通过添加额外的变量,我们可以消除这些故事的歧义。此外,在由此产生的因果关系模型中,因果关系的HP定义给出了直观上正确的答案。它还表明,通过添加额外的变量,修改原来的HP定义处理霍普金斯和珍珠的例子可能是没有必要的。考虑到通过增加额外的变量可以做多少事情,可能会有人担心因果关系的概念有些不稳定。可以以“保守”的方式添加额外的变量(即,保持原始模型中变量之间的所有关系)导致问题“X=x是Y=y的原因吗”的答案在“是”和“否”之间交替。结果表明,我们可以有这样的交替无限频繁,但如果我们考虑正规性,我们不能。实际上,在适当的正态假设下。添加一个额外的变量可以将答案从“yes”更改为“no”,但在此之后,它不能再更改回“yes”。

英文摘要:

Causal models defined in terms of structural equations have proved to be quite a powerful way of representing knowledge regarding causality. However, a number of authors have given examples that seem to show that the Halpern-Pearl (HP) definition of causality gives intuitively unreasonable answers. Here it is shown that, for each of these examples, we can give two stories consistent with the description in the example, such that intuitions regarding causality are quite different for each story. By adding additional variables, we can disambiguate the stories. Moreover, in the resulting causal models, the HP definition of causality gives the intuitively correct answer. It is also shown that, by adding extra variables, a modification to the original HP definition made to deal with an example of Hopkins and Pearl may not be necessary. Given how much can be done by adding extra variables, there might be a concern that the notion of causality is somewhat unstable. Can adding extra variables in a "conservative" way (i.e., maintaining all the relations between the variables in the original model) cause the answer to the question "Is X=x a cause of Y=y" to alternate between "yes" and "no"? It is shown that we can have such alternation infinitely often, but if we take normality into consideration, we cannot. Indeed, under appropriate normality assumptions. adding an extra variable can change the answer from "yes" to "no", but after that, it cannot cannot change back to "yes".

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑