arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1406.4294physics.soc-phcs.GTq-bio.PE
收藏

好的行为会激发他人的好行为吗?

Do good actions inspire good actions in others?

Valerio Capraro, Alessandra Marcelletti

摘要:

分享食物和合作以实现共同目标等行动在人类社会的演变中发挥了根本作用。这些好的行为可能不会使参与者的收益最大化,但它们会使其他人的收益最大化。因此,它们的存在令进化论感到困惑。为什么你要努力帮助别人,即使在没有回报的情况下?事实上,实验通常表明,人类是异质的:有些人可能会帮助别人,而另一些人可能不会。为了支持“成功文化”的出现,最近有一些研究调查了什么机制促进了一个特定的良好行为的演变。但是,人们对好的行为是否以及如何在人与人之间传播仍然知之甚少。例如,接受利他行为是否会增加你与他人合作的可能性?柏拉图的名言“善行给我们力量,激励他人善行”表明这是可能的。我们在亚马逊土耳其机器人上进行了一项实验,使用经济游戏来测试这种机制。我们通过一个标准的囚徒困境来衡量合作的意愿,并使用二元独裁者博弈来衡量利他行为的意愿。在基线处理中,游戏所需的天赋是由实验者提供的,和往常一样;在控制处理中,它们来自其他人的一个好动作。在四个不同的比较中,共有572名受试者,我们从未发现当捐赠来自一个好的行为时,合作或利他主义会显著增加。我们的结论是,良好的行为不一定会激发他人的良好行为,至少在匿名实验室实验的理想情况下。

英文摘要:

Actions such as sharing food and cooperating to reach a common goal have played a fundamental role in the evolution of human societies. These good actions may not maximise the actor's payoff, but they maximise the other's payoff. Consequently, their existence is puzzling for evolutionary theories. Why should you make an effort to help others, even when no reward seems to be at stake? Indeed, experiments typically show that humans are heterogeneous: some may help others, while others may not. With the aim of favouring the emergence of 'successful cultures', a number of studies has recently investigated what mechanisms promote the evolution of a particular good action. But still little is known about if and how good actions can spread from person to person. For instance, does being recipient of an altruistic act increase your probability of being cooperative with others? Plato's quote, 'Good actions give strength to ourselves and inspire good actions in others', suggests that is possible. We have conducted an experiment on Amazon Mechanical Turk to test this mechanism using economic games. We have measured willingness to be cooperative through a standard Prisoner's dilemma and willingness to act altruistically using a binary Dictator game. In the baseline treatments, the endowments needed to play were given by the experimenters, as usual; in the control treatments, they came from a good action made by someone else. Across four different comparisons and a total of 572 subjects, we have never found a significant increase of cooperation or altruism when the endowment came from a good action. We conclude that good actions do not necessarily inspire good actions in others, at least in the ideal scenario of a lab experiment with anonymous subjects.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑