arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1404.1334astro-ph.EP
收藏

专家和社区陨石坑分析师对陨石坑识别的差异

The variability of crater identification among expert and community crater analysts

Stuart J. Robbins, Irene Antonenko, Michelle R. Kirchoff, Clark R. Chapman, Caleb I. Fassett, Robert R. Herrick, Kelsi Singer, Michael Zanetti, Cory Lehan, Di Huang, Pamela L. Gay

摘要:

确定行星表面的撞击坑提供了有关其地质历史的重要信息。大多数研究都依赖于个人分析师,他们绘制和识别陨石坑并解释陨石坑统计数据。然而,很少有工作已经完成,以确定如何计数变化的功能,技术,地形,或研究人员之间。此外,一些新颖的基于互联网的项目要求志愿者几乎没有接受过任何培训来识别陨石坑,目前还不清楚他们的结果与典型的专业研究人员相比如何。为了更好地了解专家之间的差异,并与志愿者进行比较,八名专业研究人员在月球的两个不同区域确定了撞击特征。小陨石坑(直径从10米到500米不等)在月海区域进行了测量,较大的陨石坑(直径100米到几公里)在月球高地和月海进行了测量。志愿者的数据收集的小陨石坑的母马。我们的比较表明,专家之间的协议水平取决于火山口直径,每个直径箱的火山口数量,地形类型,差异高达$\sim\pm45%$。我们还发现文物附近的最小陨石坑直径的研究。这些结果表明,在大多数情况下,必须谨慎使用时,解释陨石坑的大小频率分布和陨石坑$\le10$像素的小变化。由于发现的自然变异性,强调许多人在同一地区识别陨石坑并使用共识结果的项目可能会产生最一致和最可靠的信息。

英文摘要:

The identification of impact craters on planetary surfaces provides important information about their geological history. Most studies have relied on individual analysts who map and identify craters and interpret crater statistics. However, little work has been done to determine how the counts vary as a function of technique, terrain, or between researchers. Furthermore, several novel internet-based projects ask volunteers with little to no training to identify craters, and it was unclear how their results compare against the typical professional researcher. To better understand the variation among experts and to compare with volunteers, eight professional researchers have identified impact features in two separate regions of the moon. Small craters (diameters ranging from 10 m to 500 m) were measured on a lunar mare region and larger craters (100s m to a few km in diameter) were measured on both lunar highlands and maria. Volunteer data were collected for the small craters on the mare. Our comparison shows that the level of agreement among experts depends on crater diameter, number of craters per diameter bin, and terrain type, with differences of up to $\sim\pm45%$. We also found artifacts near the minimum crater diameter that was studied. These results indicate that caution must be used in most cases when interpreting small variations in crater size-frequency distributions and for craters $\le10$ pixels across. Because of the natural variability found, projects that emphasize many people identifying craters on the same area and using a consensus result are likely to yield the most consistent and robust information.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑