The physical equations determining the motion of moist atmospheric air in the presence of condensation remain controversial. Two distinct formulations have been proposed, published and cited. The equation of Bannon [2002, J. Atmos. Sci. 59: 1967--1982] includes a term for a "reactive motion" that arises when water vapor condenses and droplets begin to fall; according to this term the remaining gas moves upwards so as to conserve momentum. In the equation of Ooyama[2001, J. Atmos. Sci. 58: 2073--2102] the reactive motion term is absent. Both equations contain a term for condensate loading, but in the formulation of Ooyama [2001] there are two additional terms. In some modern nonhydrostatic models of moist atmospheric circulation, however, formulations have been mixed. Here we examine the contrasting equations for the motion of moist air. We discuss inconsistencies in the application of Newton's second and third laws to an air and condensate mixture. We show that the concept of reactive motion in this context is based on a misunderstanding of the conservation of momentum in the presence of a gravitational field: such a reactive motion does not exist. We show that the "mixed" equation used in some models is not physically consistent either. We examine why consideration of total momentum, that is air and condensate combined, has been misleading in the search for valid equations of motion in the presence of phase transitions.
Moist-entropic vertical adiabatic lapse rates: the standard cases and some lead towards inhomogeneous conditions
本注记是Marquet and Geleyn(2013,{arXiv:1401.2379 [ao-ph]})的姊妹篇,其中绝热递减率$Γ_{ns}$和$Γ_{sw}$是针对非饱和($Γ_{ns}$)或饱和($Γ_{sw}$)的稀薄空气块导出的。它们是根据Marquet(2011,{arXiv:1401.1097 [ao-ph]})中定义的大气熵位温$θ_s$的垂直导数计算的。本文对饱和值$Γ_{sw}$进行了改写,从而得到了一个更紧凑的公式。$Γ_{sw}$的新公式用加权因子$C$表示。该因子可以表示处于饱和条件的气团的比例。
A new model for simulating heat, air and moisture transport in porous building materials
LOCIE–CNRS, Université Savoie Mont Blanc(萨瓦-蒙布朗大学);LAMA–CNRS, Université Savoie Mont Blanc(萨瓦-蒙布朗大学);Pontifical Catholic University of Paraná(巴拉那天主教大学);IIT University(阿拉木图工业大学)