arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1509.09096physics.ao-phphysics.flu-dynphysics.geo-ph
收藏

关于“MSE减去CAPE是绝热抬升地块的真守恒变量”的评论

Comments on "MSE minus CAPE is the True Conserved Variable for an Adiabatically Lifted Parcel"

Pascal Marquet

摘要:

在最近的一篇论文中,Romps(JAS,第72卷,第3639 -3646页,2015年,以下简称R15)认为,对流-空气静态能量(MSE)仅近似地守恒于对流抬升的包裹,并且量“MSE-CAPE”可以用作真正的守恒变量,其中CAPE是对流可用能量。本文指出,R15中CAPE所表示的量与对流有效能相反。据解释,R15中考虑的垂直绝热上升是不现实的,因为它在6 km以上的高度产生10至20 g/kg量级的冷凝水。此外,热力学方程在R15中是通过几个假设写成的,并不是所有的假设都被明确提到。本文旨在澄清R15中的假设。它将表明,这些假设提出了问题的有效性,空气内能,焓和熵的功能在R15。它还表明,它是可能的,特别是通过使用热力学第三定律,获得更精确和更一般的配方的空气能量,焓和熵函数。通过研究一个真实的拟绝热垂直剖面,说明了R15中导出的热力学公式与第三定律的热力学公式之间的巨大差异。本评注将尽可能使用与R15相同的符号。

英文摘要:

In a recent paper, Romps (JAS, vol.72, p.3639-3646, 2015, hereafter R15) argues that the moist-air static energy (MSE) is only approximately conserved for an adiabatically lifted parcel, and that the quantity "MSE - CAPE" could be used as a true conserved variable, where CAPE is the convective available energy. It is shown in this comment that the quantity denoted by CAPE in R15 is the opposite of the convective available energy. It is explained that the vertical adiabatic ascent considered in R15 is not realistic, since it generates condensed water of the order of 10 to 20 g/kg at height above 6 km. Moreover, the thermodynamic equations are written in R15 by making several assumptions, not all of which are explicitly mentioned. This comment aims to clarify the hypotheses made in R15. It will show that these assumptions call into question the validity of the moist-air internal energy, enthalpy and entropy functions in R15. It also demonstrates that it is possible to obtain more precise and general formulations for moist-air energy, enthalpy and entropy functions, in particular by using the third law of thermodynamics. The large differences between the thermodynamics formulas derived in R15 and those depending on the third law are illustrated by studying a realistic pseudo-adiabatic vertical profile. The same notations as in R15 will be used as far as possible in this comment.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑