Despite the fact that size-based schedulers can give excellent results in terms of both average response times and fairness, data-intensive computing execution engines generally do not employ size-based schedulers, mainly because of the fact that job size is not known a priori.
In this work, we perform a simulation-based analysis of the performance of size-based schedulers when they are employed with the workload of typical data-intensive schedules and with approximated size estimations. We show results that are very promising: even when size estimation is very imprecise, response times of size-based schedulers can be definitely smaller than those of simple scheduling techniques such as processor sharing or FIFO.
One of the hot problems in grid computing is job scheduling. It is known that the job scheduling is NP-complete, and thus the use of heuristics is the de facto approach to deal with this practice in its difficulty. The proposed is an imagination to fish swarm, job dispatcher and Visualization gridsim to execute some jobs.
The ever-growing processing power of supercomputers in recent decades enables us to explore increasing complex scientific problems. Effective scheduling these jobs is crucial for individual job performance and system efficiency. The traditional job schedulers in high performance computing (HPC) are simple and concentrate on improving CPU utilization. The emergence of new hardware resources and novel hardware structure impose severe challenges on traditional schedulers. The increasing diverse workloads, including compute-intensive and data-intensive applications, require more efficient schedule…
Diverse workloads such as interactive supercomputing, big data analysis, and large-scale AI algorithm development, requires a high-performance scheduler. This paper presents a novel node-based scheduling approach for large scale simulations of short running jobs on MIT SuperCloud systems, that allows the resources to be fully utilized for both long running batch jobs while simultaneously providing fast launch and release of large-scale short running jobs. The node-based scheduling approach has demonstrated up to 100 times faster scheduler performance that other state-of-the-art systems.
It is cost-efficient for a tenant with a limited budget to establish a virtual MapReduce cluster by renting multiple virtual private servers (VPSs) from a VPS provider. To provide an appropriate scheduling scheme for this type of computing environment, we propose in this paper a hybrid job-driven scheduling scheme (JoSS for short) from a tenant's perspective. JoSS provides not only job level scheduling, but also map-task level scheduling and reduce-task level scheduling. JoSS classifies MapReduce jobs based on job scale and job type and designs an appropriate scheduling policy to schedule each…
The use of meta-schedulers for resource management in large-scale distributed systems often leads to a hierarchy of schedulers. In this paper, we discuss why existing meta-scheduling hierarchies are sometimes not sufficient for Grid systems due to their inability to re-organise jobs already scheduled locally. Such a job re-organisation is required to adapt to evolving loads which are common in heavily used Grid infrastructures. We propose a peer-to-peer scheduling model and evaluate it using case studies and mathematical modelling. We detail the DIANA (Data Intensive and Network Aware) schedul…
Grid computing is the recently growing area of computing that share data, storage, computing across geographically dispersed area. This paper proposes a novel fuzzy approach using Differential Evolution (DE) for scheduling jobs on computational grids. The fuzzy based DE generates an optimal plan to complete the jobs within a minimum period of time. We evaluate the performance of the proposed fuzzy based DE algorithm with Genetic Algorithm (GA), Simulated Annealing (SA), Differential Evolution and fuzzy PSO. Experimental results have shown that the new algorithm produces more optimal solutions …
High-performance computing (HPC) is undergoing significant changes. Next generation HPC systems are equipped with diverse global and local resources, such as I/O burst buffer resources, memory resources (e.g., on-chip and off-chip RAM, external RAM/NVRA), network resources, and possibly other resources. Job schedulers play a crucial role in efficient use of resources. However, traditional job schedulers are single-objective and fail to efficient use of other resources. In this paper, we propose ROME, a novel multi-dimensional job scheduling framework to explore potential tradeoffs among multip…
We propose throughput and cost optimal job scheduling algorithms in cloud computing platforms offering Infrastructure as a Service. We first consider online migration and propose job scheduling algorithms to minimize job migration and server running costs. We consider algorithms that assume knowledge of job-size on arrival of jobs. We characterize the optimal cost subject to system stability. We develop a drift-plus-penalty framework based algorithm that can achieve optimal cost arbitrarily closely. Specifically this algorithm yields a trade-off between delay and costs. We then relax the job-s…
We present AccaSim, a simulator for workload management in HPC systems. Thanks to AccaSim's scalability to large workload datasets, support for easy customization, and practical automated tools to aid experimentation, users can easily represent various real HPC systems, develop novel advanced dispatchers and evaluate them in a convenient way across different workload sources. AccaSim is thus an attractive tool for conducting job dispatching research in HPC systems.
MapReduce is emerged as a prominent programming model for data-intensive computation. In this work, we study power-aware MapReduce scheduling in the speed scaling setting first introduced by Yao et al. [FOCS 1995]. We focus on the minimization of the total weighted completion time of a set of MapReduce jobs under a given budget of energy. Using a linear programming relaxation of our problem, we derive a polynomial time constant-factor approximation algorithm. We also propose a convex programming formulation that we combine with standard list scheduling policies, and we evaluate their performan…
With the rapidly growing demand of graph processing in the real scene, they have to efficiently handle massive concurrent jobs. Although existing work enable to efficiently handle single graph processing job, there are plenty of memory access redundancy caused by ignoring the characteristic of data access correlations. Motivated such an observation, we proposed two-level scheduling strategy in this paper, which enables to enhance the efficiency of data access and to accelerate the convergence speed of concurrent jobs. Firstly, correlations-aware job scheduling allows concurrent jobs to process…
The proliferation of multi-core and multiprocessor-based computer systems has led to explosive development of parallel applications and hence the need for efficient schedulers. In this paper, we study hierarchical scheduling for malleable parallel jobs on multiprocessor-based systems, which appears in many distributed and multilayered computing environments. We propose a hierarchical scheduling algorithm, named AC-DS, that consists of a feedback-driven adaptive scheduler, a desire aggregation scheme and an efficient resource allocation policy. From theoretical perspective, we show that AC-DS h…
In hadoop, the job scheduling is an independent module, users can design their own job scheduler based on their actual application requirements, thereby meet their specific business needs. Currently, hadoop has three schedulers: FIFO, computing capacity scheduling and fair scheduling policy, all of them are take task allocation strategy that considerate data locality simply. They neither support data locality well nor fully apply to all cases of jobs scheduling. In this paper, we took the concept of resources-prefetch into consideration, and proposed a job scheduling algorithm based on data lo…
In data-intensive applications data transfer is a primary cause of job execution delay. Data access time depends on bandwidth. The major bottleneck to supporting fast data access in Grids is the high latencies of Wide Area Networks and Internet. Effective scheduling can reduce the amount of data transferred across the internet by dispatching a job to where the needed data are present. Another solution is to use a data replication mechanism. Objective of dynamic replica strategies is reducing file access time which leads to reducing job runtime. In this paper we develop a job scheduling policy …
The ability to accurately estimate job runtime properties allows a scheduler to effectively schedule jobs. State-of-the-art online cluster job schedulers use history-based learning, which uses past job execution information to estimate the runtime properties of newly arrived jobs. However, with fast-paced development in cluster technology (in both hardware and software) and changing user inputs, job runtime properties can change over time, which lead to inaccurate predictions. In this paper, we explore the potential and limitation of real-time learning of job runtime properties, by proactively…
Nowadays large-scale distributed machine learning systems have been deployed to support various analytics and intelligence services in IT firms. To train a large dataset and derive the prediction/inference model, e.g., a deep neural network, multiple workers are run in parallel to train partitions of the input dataset, and update shared model parameters. In a shared cluster handling multiple training jobs, a fundamental issue is how to efficiently schedule jobs and set the number of concurrent workers to run for each job, such that server resources are maximally utilized and model training can…
Advance reservation is important to guarantee the quality of services of jobs by allowing exclusive access to resources over a defined time interval on resources. It is a challenge for the scheduler to organize available resources efficiently and to allocate them for parallel AR jobs with deadline constraint appropriately. This paper provides a slot-based data structure to organize available resources of multiprocessor systems in a way that enables efficient search and update operations, and formulates a suite of scheduling policies to allocate resources for dynamically arriving AR requests. T…
In job scheduling, the concept of malleability has been explored since many years ago. Research shows that malleability improves system performance, but its utilization in HPC never became widespread. The causes are the difficulty in developing malleable applications, and the lack of support and integration of the different layers of the HPC software stack. However, in the last years, malleability in job scheduling is becoming more critical because of the increasing complexity of hardware and workloads. In this context, using nodes in an exclusive mode is not always the most efficient solution…
For a cloud service provider, delivering optimal system performance while fulfilling Quality of Service (QoS) obligations is critical for maintaining a viably profitable business. This goal is often hard to attain given the irregular nature of cloud computing jobs. These jobs expect high QoS on an on-demand fashion, that is on random arrival. To optimize the response to such client demands, cloud service providers organize the cloud computing environment as a multi-tier architecture. Each tier executes its designated tasks and passes the job to the next tier; in a fashion similar, but not iden…
Efficient scheduling of distributed deep learning (DL) jobs in large GPU clusters is crucial for resource efficiency and job performance. While server sharing among jobs improves resource utilization, interference among co-located DL jobs occurs due to resource contention. Interference-aware job placement has been studied, with white-box approaches based on explicit interference modeling and black-box schedulers with reinforcement learning. In today's clusters containing thousands of GPU servers, running a single scheduler to manage all arrival jobs in a timely and effective manner is challeng…
In a large-scale computing cluster, the job completions can be substantially delayed due to two sources of variability, namely, variability in the job size and that in the machine service capacity. To tackle this issue, existing works have proposed various scheduling algorithms which exploit redundancy wherein a job runs on multiple servers until the first completes. In this paper, we explore the impact of variability in the machine service capacity and adopt a rigorous analytical approach to design scheduling algorithms using redundancy and checkpointing. We design several online scheduling a…
The ever-increasing gap between compute and I/O performance in HPC platforms, together with the development of novel NVMe storage devices (NVRAM), led to the emergence of the burst buffer concept - an intermediate persistent storage layer logically positioned between random-access main memory and a parallel file system. Despite the development of real-world architectures as well as research concepts, resource and job management systems, such as Slurm, provide only marginal support for scheduling jobs with burst buffer requirements, in particular ignoring burst buffers when backfilling. We inve…
The current Cloud infrastructure services (IaaS) market employs a resource-based selling model: customers rent nodes from the provider and pay per-node per-unit-time. This selling model places the burden upon customers to predict their job resource requirements and durations. Inaccurate prediction by customers can result in over-provisioning of resources, or under-provisioning and poor job performance. Thanks to improved resource virtualization and multi-tenant performance isolation, as well as common frameworks for batch jobs, such as MapReduce, Cloud providers can predict job completion time…
We study the problem of scheduling jobs on fault-prone machines communicating via a shared channel, also known as multiple-access channel. We have $n$ arbitrary length jobs to be scheduled on $m$ identical machines, $f$ of which are prone to crashes by an adversary. A machine can inform other machines when a job is completed via the channel without collision detection. Performance is measured by the total number of available machine steps during the whole execution. Our goal is to study the impact of preemption (i.e., interrupting the execution of a job and resuming later in the same or differ…
This paper discussed some job scheduling algorithms for Hadoop platform, and proposed a jobs scheduling optimization algorithm based on Bayes Classification viewing the shortcoming of those algorithms which are used. The proposed algorithm can be summarized as follows. In the scheduling algorithm based on Bayes Classification, the jobs in job queue will be classified into bad job and good job by Bayes Classification, when JobTracker gets task request, it will select a good job from job queue, and select tasks from good job to allocate JobTracker, then the execution result will feedback to the …
We consider a distributed computing network consisting of a master and multiple workers processing tasks of different types. The master is running multiple applications. Each application stochastically generates real-time jobs with a strict job deadline, where each job is a collection of tasks of some types specified by the application. A real-time job is completed only when all its tasks are completed by the corresponding workers within the deadline. Moreover, we consider unreliable workers, whose processing speeds are uncertain. Because of the limited processing abilities of the workers, an …
The University of Tokyo（东京大学）；Preferred Networks, Inc.（优选网络公司）
One significant challenge in the job scheduling of computing clusters for the development of deep learning algorithms is the efficient scheduling of trial-and-error (TE) job, the type of job in which the users seek to conduct small-scale experiments while monitoring their processes. Unfortunately, the existing job schedulers to date do not feature well-balanced scheduling for the mixture of TE jobs and best-effort (BE) jobs, or they can handle the mixture in limited situations at most. To fill in this niche, we propose an algorithm that can significantly reduce the latency of TE jobs in versat…
We are interested in the optimal scheduling of a collection of multi-component application jobs in an edge computing system that consists of geo-distributed edge computing nodes connected through a wide area network. The scheduling and placement of application jobs in an edge system is challenging due to the interdependence of multiple components of each job, and the communication delays between the geographically distributed data sources and edge nodes and their dynamic availability. In this paper we explore the feasibility of applying Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) based design to address…
One of the main challenges in Grid systems is designing an adaptive, scalable, and model-independent method for job scheduling to achieve a desirable degree of load balancing and system efficiency. Centralized job scheduling methods have some drawbacks, such as single point of failure and lack of scalability. Moreover, decentralized methods require a coordination mechanism with limited communications. In this paper, we propose a multi-agent approach to job scheduling in Grid, named Centralized Learning Distributed Scheduling (CLDS), by utilizing the reinforcement learning framework. The CLDS i…
Computational Grids are a new trend in distributed computing systems. They allow the sharing of geographically distributed resources in an efficient way, extending the boundaries of what we perceive as distributed computing. Various sciences can benefit from the use of grids to solve CPU-intensive problems, creating potential benefits to the entire society. Job scheduling is an integrated part of parallel and distributed computing. It allows selecting correct match of resource for a particular job and thus increases the job throughput and utilization of resources. Job should be scheduled in an…
This paper studies a model for online job scheduling in green datacenters. In green datacenters, resource availability depends on the power supply from the renewables. Intermittent power supply from renewables leads to intermittent resource availability, inducing job delays (and associated costs). Green datacenter operators must intelligently manage their workloads and available power supply to extract maximum benefits. The scheduler's objective is to schedule jobs on a set of resources to maximize the total value (revenue) while minimizing the overall job delay. A trade-off exists between ach…
Baidu Inc.（百度公司）；Soochow University（苏州大学）；Auburn University（奥本大学）；North Carolina State University（北卡罗来纳州立大学）
Recent years have witnessed a large amount of decentralized data in various (edge) devices of end-users, while the decentralized data aggregation remains complicated for machine learning jobs because of regulations and laws. As a practical approach to handling decentralized data, Federated Learning (FL) enables collaborative global machine learning model training without sharing sensitive raw data. The servers schedule devices to jobs within the training process of FL. In contrast, device scheduling with multiple jobs in FL remains a critical and open problem. In this paper, we propose a novel…
We study the performance of non-adaptive scheduling policies in computing systems with multiple servers. Compute jobs are mostly regular, with modest service requirements. However, there are sporadic data intensive jobs, whose expected service time is much higher than that of the regular jobs. Forthis model, we are interested in the effect of scheduling policieson the average time a job spends in the system. To this end, we introduce two performance indicators in a simplified, only-arrival system. We believe that these performance indicators are good predictors of the relative performance of t…
The IT organizations invests heavy capital by consuming large scale infrastructure and advanced operating platforms. The advances in technology has resulted in emergence of cloud computing, which is promising technology to achieve the aforementioned objective. At the peak hours, the jobs arriving to the cloud system are normally high demanding efficient execution and dispatch. An observation that has been carried out in this paper by capturing a job arriving pattern from a monitoring system explains that most of the jobs get rejected because of lack of efficient technology. The job rejections …
Research Center of Smart Networks and Systems, Fudan University（复旦大学智慧网络与系统研究中心）；School of Operations Research and Information Engineering, Cornell University（康奈尔大学运筹学与信息工程学院）
Minimizing job scheduling time is a fundamental issue in data center networks that has been extensively studied in recent years. The incoming jobs require different CPU and memory units, and span different number of time slots. The traditional solution is to design efficient heuristic algorithms with performance guarantee under certain assumptions. In this paper, we improve a recently proposed job scheduling algorithm using deep reinforcement learning and extend it to multiple server clusters. Our study reveals that deep reinforcement learning method has the potential to outperform traditional…
Coflow is a recently proposed networking abstraction to help improve the communication performance of data-parallel computing jobs. In multi-stage jobs, each job consists of multiple coflows and is represented by a Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG). Efficiently scheduling coflows is critical to improve the data-parallel computing performance in data centers. Compared with hand-tuned scheduling heuristics, existing work DeepWeave [1] utilizes Reinforcement Learning (RL) framework to generate highly-efficient coflow scheduling policies automatically. It employs a graph neural network (GNN) to encode …
Department of Computer Science, Hong Kong Baptist University（香港浸会大学计算机科学系）
Distributed Deep Learning (DDL) has rapidly grown its popularity since it helps boost the training performance on high-performance GPU clusters. Efficient job scheduling is indispensable to maximize the overall performance of the cluster when training multiple jobs simultaneously. However, existing schedulers do not consider the communication contention of multiple communication tasks from different distributed training jobs, which could deteriorate the system performance and prolong the job completion time. In this paper, we first establish a new DDL job scheduling framework which organizes D…
Scheduling is important in Edge computing. In contrast to the Cloud, Edge resources are hardware limited and cannot support workload-driven infrastructure scaling. Hence, resource allocation and scheduling for the Edge requires a fresh perspective. Existing Edge scheduling research assumes availability of all needed resources whenever a job request is made. This paper challenges that assumption, since not all job requests from a Cloud server can be scheduled on an Edge node. Thus, guaranteeing fairness among the clients (Cloud servers offloading jobs) while accounting for priorities of the job…
We describe in this paper a new method for building an efficient algorithm for scheduling jobs in a cluster. Jobs are considered as parallel tasks (PT) which can be scheduled on any number of processors. The main feature is to consider two criteria that are optimized together. These criteria are the makespan and the weighted minimal average completion time (minsum). They are chosen for their complementarity, to be able to represent both user-oriented objectives and system administrator objectives. We propose an algorithm based on a batch policy with increasing batch sizes, with a smart selecti…
Energy consumption is one of the most critical concerns in designing computing devices, ranging from portable embedded systems to computer cluster systems. Furthermore, in the past decade, cluster systems have increasingly risen as popular platforms to run computing-intensive real-time applications in which the performance is of great importance. However, due to different characteristics of real-time workloads, developing general job scheduling solutions that efficiently address both energy consumption and performance in real-time cluster systems is a challenging problem. In this paper, inspir…
Complex scientific workflows can process large amounts of data using thousands of tasks. The turnaround times of these workflows are often affected by various latencies such as the resource discovery, scheduling and data access latencies for the individual workflow processes or actors. Minimizing these latencies will improve the overall execution time of a workflow and thus lead to a more efficient and robust processing environment. In this paper, we propose a pilot job based infrastructure that has intelligent data reuse and job execution strategies to minimize the scheduling, queuing, execut…
Fairness-Aware Job Scheduling for Multi-Job Federated Learning
Nanyang Technological University（南洋理工大学）；DSO National Laboratories（DSO国家实验室）；Alibaba Group（阿里巴巴集团）；Alibaba-NTU Singapore Joint Research Institute（阿里巴巴-新加坡南洋理工大学联合研究院）
Optimizing data transfers is critical for improving job performance in data-parallel frameworks. In the hybrid data center with both wired and wireless links, reconfigurable wireless links can provide additional bandwidth to speed up job execution. However, it requires the scheduler and transceivers to make joint decisions under coupled constraints. In this work, we identify that the joint job scheduling and bandwidth augmentation problem is a complex mixed integer nonlinear problem, which is not solvable by existing optimization methods. To address this bottleneck, we transform it into an equ…
Queuing systems with redundant requests have drawn great attention because of their promise to reduce the job completion time and variability. Despite a large body of work on the topic, we are still far from fully understanding the benefits of redundancy in practice. We here take one step towards practical systems by studying queuing systems with bi-modal job service time distribution. Such distributions have been observed in practice, as can be seen in, e.g., Google cluster traces. We develop an analogy to a classical urns and balls problem, and use it to study the queuing time performance of…
There is a general trend towards solving problems suited to deep learning with more complex deep learning architectures trained on larger training sets. This requires longer compute times and greater data parallelization or model parallelization. Both data and model parallelism have been historically faster in parameter server architectures, but data parallelism is starting to be faster in ring architectures due to algorithmic improvements. In this paper, we analyze the math behind ring architectures and make an informed adaptation of dynamic scheduling to ring architectures. To do so, we form…
Recent years have witnessed a large amount of decentralized data in multiple (edge) devices of end-users, while the aggregation of the decentralized data remains difficult for machine learning jobs due to laws or regulations. Federated Learning (FL) emerges as an effective approach to handling decentralized data without sharing the sensitive raw data, while collaboratively training global machine learning models. The servers in FL need to select (and schedule) devices during the training process. However, the scheduling of devices for multiple jobs with FL remains a critical and open problem. …
Applications in data-parallel computing typically consist of multiple stages. In each stage, a set of intermediate parallel data flows (Coflow) is produced and transferred between servers to enable starting of next stage. While there has been much research on scheduling isolated coflows, the dependency between coflows in multi-stage jobs has been largely ignored. In this paper, we consider scheduling coflows of multi-stage jobs represented by general DAGs (Directed Acyclic Graphs) in a shared data center network, so as to minimize the total weighted completion time of jobs. This problem is sig…
