arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1304.3440cs.AI
收藏

基于区间的推理系统决策

Interval-Based Decisions for Reasoning Systems

Ronald P. Loui

摘要:

本文着眼于决策与区间值概率措施。现有的决策方法要么补充期望效用方法与其他标准的最优性,或试图补充区间值的措施。我们提倡一种新的方法,它使以下问题变得毫无意义:1。使用哪些附加标准,以及2.间隔应该有多宽为了实现这一方法,我们需要更多的认识论信息。这种信息可以通过接受规则产生,并带有允许对错误采取各种态度的参数,或者可以简单地声明。在草图中,论点是:1。概率区间在All中是有用和自然的。系统; 2.较宽的区间可以避免错误,但在某些风险敏感的决策中是无用的; 3.如果不那么谨慎,则可以获得更窄的间隔; 4.如果知识体系可以按照其谨慎程度来排序,则应该使用那些有用的知识体系中最谨慎的可接受的知识体系来执行决策分析。由此产生的行为不同于行为概率论者(贝叶斯),因为在建议中,5。基于连续知识体的区间并不总是嵌套的; 6.如果代理人使用特定决策的概率,则她不需要承诺用于信任或未来决策的该概率;以及7.可能没有可接受的有用的知识体系;因此,有时没有规定作出任何决定。

英文摘要:

This essay looks at decision-making with interval-valued probability measures. Existing decision methods have either supplemented expected utility methods with additional criteria of optimality, or have attempted to supplement the interval-valued measures. We advocate a new approach, which makes the following questions moot: 1. which additional criteria to use, and 2. how wide intervals should be. In order to implement the approach, we need more epistemological information. Such information can be generated by a rule of acceptance with a parameter that allows various attitudes toward error, or can simply be declared. In sketch, the argument is: 1. probability intervals are useful and natural in All. systems; 2. wide intervals avoid error, but are useless in some risk sensitive decision-making; 3. one may obtain narrower intervals if one is less cautious; 4. if bodies of knowledge can be ordered by their caution, one should perform the decision analysis with the acceptable body of knowledge that is the most cautious, of those that are useful. The resulting behavior differs from that of a behavioral probabilist (a Bayesian) because in the proposal, 5. intervals based on successive bodies of knowledge are not always nested; 6. if the agent uses a probability for a particular decision, she need not commit to that probability for credence or future decision; and 7. there may be no acceptable body of knowledge that is useful; hence, sometimes no decision is mandated.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑