在线审议设计:选择,标准和证据
Online Deliberation Design: Choices, Criteria, and Evidence
摘要:
本章回顾了经验证据轴承的审议公民参与的在线论坛的设计。设计的维度被定义为不同方面的审议:其目的,目标人群,时空距离分离的参与者,通信媒介,审议过程中要遵循。在简要概述了评估不同设计方案的标准后,围绕设计选择组织了实证研究结果。研究已经从对在线审议技术的二分法(存在或不存在)发展到区分技术特征,使用它们的方式和文化环境的细微差别。在线审议的有效性取决于沟通环境与审议任务的匹配程度。在丰富和贫乏的媒体之间以及在匿名和可识别的参与之间进行权衡,这表明根据目的和参与者而有不同的设计。调查结果受到现有技术的限制,并可能随着技术和用户的共同发展而改变。
英文摘要:
This chapter reviews empirical evidence bearing on the design of online forums for deliberative civic engagement. Dimensions of design are defined for different aspects of the deliberation: its purpose, the target population, the spatiotemporal distance separating participants, the communication medium, and the deliberative process to be followed. After a brief overview of criteria for evaluating different design options, empirical findings are organized around design choices. Research has evolved away from treating technology for online deliberation dichotomously (either present or not) toward nuanced findings that differentiate between technological features, ways of using them, and cultural settings. The effectiveness of online deliberation depends on how well the communicative environment is matched to the deliberative task. Tradeoffs, e.g. between rich and lean media and between anonymous and identifiable participation, suggest different designs depending on the purpose and participants. Findings are limited by existing technologies, and may change as technologies and users co-evolve.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。