不长也不短:在线审议平台中“最优”反思时长的 Goldilocks 原则
Not Too Long, Not Too Short: Goldilocks Principle of 'Optimal' Reflection Time on Online Deliberation Platforms
AI总结:
针对在线审议中反思时长影响研究不足的问题,本文通过两项用户研究确定了短评论撰写的最优反思时长,测试了四种界面时间引导的效果,发现其可延长反思时长,对体验影响不一,且反思时长对低于最优阈值的用户尤为重要。
摘要:
在线平台的审议潜力已得到广泛研究,但反思时长对审议质量的影响仍有待深入探究。本文开展了两项分别涉及100名和72名参与者的用户研究,以探究分钟级审议中反思时长对审议质量的影响。在第一项研究中,我们确定了撰写简短意见评论的最优反思时长。在第二项研究中,我们引入了四种不同的基于界面的时间引导(time nudge),旨在鼓励用户在接近最优时长的时间点进行反思。尽管这些引导可能无法提升审议质量,但它们有效延长了反思时长。此外,我们观察到这些引导对用户体验的影响好坏参半,具体取决于时间引导的性质。我们的研究结果表明,反思时长至关重要,对于那些通常审议时长低于最优反思阈值的用户而言尤其如此。
英文摘要:
The deliberative potential of online platforms has been widely examined but the impact of reflection time on the quality of deliberation remains under-explored. This paper presents two user studies involving 100 and 72 participants respectively, to investigate the impact of reflection time on the quality of deliberation in minute-scale deliberations. In the first study, we identified an optimal reflection time for composing short opinion comments. In the second study, we introduced four distinct interface-based time nudges aimed at encouraging reflection near the optimal time. While these nudges may not improve the quality of deliberation, they effectively prolonged reflection periods. Additionally, we observed mixed effects on users' experience, influenced by the nature of the time nudges. Our findings suggest that reflection time is crucial, particularly for users who typically deliberate below the optimal reflection threshold.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。