评估学术机构研究绩效的方法:对应用于林业的ERA 2010的批评和作为可能替代方案的间接H2指数
Metrics to evaluate research performance in academic institutions: A critique of ERA 2010 as applied in forestry and the indirect H2 index as a possible alternative
摘要:
澳大利亚卓越研究奖(ERA)是澳大利亚研究委员会在180个研究领域内使用指标和同行评估对澳大利亚大学进行5分制评级的一种尝试。一些有助于这一排名的文献计量数据遭受与偏态分布相关的统计问题。其他数据是逐年标准化的,过分强调了最近的出版物,这些出版物可能还没有可靠的引用模式。提供给评估委员会的文献计量数据是广泛的,但缺乏有效的综合,如h指数及其变体。间接H2指数是客观的,可以自动和有效地计算,不易被操纵,是一个很好的影响指标,有助于电子逆向拍卖评价委员会和国际上的类似评价。
英文摘要:
Excellence for Research in Australia (ERA) is an attempt by the Australian Research Council to rate Australian universities on a 5-point scale within 180 Fields of Research using metrics and peer evaluation by an evaluation committee. Some of the bibliometric data contributing to this ranking suffer statistical issues associated with skewed distributions. Other data are standardised year-by-year, placing undue emphasis on the most recent publications which may not yet have reliable citation patterns. The bibliometric data offered to the evaluation committees is extensive, but lacks effective syntheses such as the h-index and its variants. The indirect H2 index is objective, can be computed automatically and efficiently, is resistant to manipulation, and a good indicator of impact to assist the ERA evaluation committees and to similar evaluations internationally.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。