我们在一个框架中结合了chi^2模板拟合和经验训练集的两个互补优势,例如在神经网络中使用:当检查其概率密度函数(PDF)的多个峰值时,chi^2更可靠,而当查询数据和训练集的校准和先验匹配时,经验训练更准确。我们提出了一种chi^2-经验方法,该方法从经验模型中导出PDF,作为核回归方法的一个子类,并将其应用于SDSS DR 5样本中> 75,000个类星体,这是充满歧义的。具有单峰PDF的物体显示<1%的离群值,均方根红移误差<0.05 and vanishing redshift bias. At z>2.5,这些数字是2倍。离群值纯粹来自模型的离散性质和有限大小,均方根误差主要由物体颜色的固有变化决定。被分类为模糊的PDF为替代解决方案提供准确的概率,从而为使用两种解决方案和避免不必要的离群值提供权重。例如,在一个示例中,PDF预测78.0%的较强峰是正确的,其中77.9%是正确的。红移不完整性在微弱的光谱调查中很常见,并在其他性能限制之上变成了一个巨大的不可检测的离群值风险,但我们可以量化模型的大小和完整性所带来的剩余离群值风险。我们提出了一个匹配的chi^2误差尺度的噪声数据,并表明,它产生正确的误差估计和红移分布的泊松误差范围内的准确。我们的方法可以很容易地应用到未来的大型星系调查,这将受益于模糊检测和剩余风险量化的可靠性。
英文摘要:
We combine in a single framework the two complementary benefits of chi^2-template fits and empirical training sets used e.g. in neural nets: chi^2 is more reliable when its probability density functions (PDFs) are inspected for multiple peaks, while empirical training is more accurate when calibration and priors of query data and training set match. We present a chi^2-empirical method that derives PDFs from empirical models as a subclass of kernel regression methods, and apply it to the SDSS DR5 sample of >75,000 QSOs, which is full of ambiguities. Objects with single-peak PDFs show <1% outliers, rms redshift errors <0.05 and vanishing redshift bias. At z>2.5, these figures are 2x better. Outliers result purely from the discrete nature and limited size of the model, and rms errors are dominated by the instrinsic variety of object colours. PDFs classed as ambiguous provide accurate probabilities for alternative solutions and thus weights for using both solutions and avoiding needless outliers. E.g., the PDFs predict 78.0% of the stronger peaks to be correct, which is true for 77.9% of them. Redshift incompleteness is common in faint spectroscopic surveys and turns into a massive undetectable outlier risk above other performance limitations, but we can quantify residual outlier risks stemming from size and completeness of the model. We propose a matched chi^2-error scale for noisy data and show that it produces correct error estimates and redshift distributions accurate within Poisson errors. Our method can easily be applied to future large galaxy surveys, which will benefit from the reliability in ambiguity detection and residual risk quantification.
Performance of Photometric Template Fitting for Ultra-High Redshift Galaxies
Cosmic Dawn Center (DAWN)(宇宙黎明中心);Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen(哥本哈根大学尼尔斯·玻尔研究所);Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Missouri(密苏里大学物理与天文学系);DARK Cosmology Center, University of Copenhagen(哥本哈根大学暗宇宙学中心);California Institute of Technology(加州理工学院)
Multi-Gaussian fitting Algorithm to determine multi-band photometry and photometric redshifts of LABOCA and Herschel sources in proto-cluster environments
Re-calibrating Photometric Redshift Probability Distributions Using Feature-space Regression
University of Pittsburgh(匹兹堡大学);Federal University of São Carlos(圣卡洛斯联邦大学);Carnegie Mellon University(卡内基梅隆大学);Argonne National Laboratory(阿贡国家实验室);Ruhr-University Bochum(波鸿鲁尔大学);German Centre for Cosmological Lensing(德国宇宙透镜中心)