Searching for Pop III stars and galaxies at high redshift
Daniel Schaerer
备注：
8 pages, invited talk, in "Low-Metallicity Star Formation: From the First Stars to Dwarf Galaxies", IAU Symp. 255, L.K. Hunt, S. Madden & R. Schneider, eds
We review the expected properties of Pop III and very metal-poor starburst and the behaviour the Lyman-alpha and HeII 1640 emission lines, which are most likely the best/easiest signatures to single out such objects. Existing claims of Pop III signatures in distant galaxies are critically examined, and the searches for HeII 1640 emission at high redshift are summarised. Finally, we briefly summarise ongoing and future deep observations at z>6 aiming in particular at detecting the sources of cosmic reionisation as well as primeval/Pop III galaxies.
We present a new photometric search for high-z galaxies hosting Population III (PopIII) stars based on deep intermediate-band imaging observations obtained in the Subaru Deep Field (SDF), by using Suprime-Cam on the Subaru Telescope. By combining our new data with the existing broad-band and narrow-band data, we searched for galaxies which emit strongly both in Ly_alpha and in HeII 1640 (``dual emitters'') that are promising candidates for PopIII-hosting galaxies, at 3.93<z<4.01 and 4.57<z<4.65. Although we found 10 ``dual emitters'', most of them turn out to be [OII]-[OIII] dual emitters or H…
We have been using the Keck I High Resolution Spectrograph (HIRES) to search for planetary companions in the Hyades cluster. We selected four stars from this sample which showed significant radial velocity variability on short timescales to search for short-period planetary companions. The radial velocities of these four stars were monitored regularly with the Hobby Eberly Telescope (HET) for approximately two months, while sparse data were also taken over ~4 months: we also obtained near-simultaneous photometric observations with one of the automatic photoelectric telescopes at Fairborn Obser…
We are investigating the hypothesis that Compact High--Velocity Clouds (CHVCs) are the left-over building blocks of Local Group galaxies. To this end, we are searching for their embedded stellar populations using FORS at the VLT. The search is done with single-star photometry in V and I bands, which is sensitive to both, young and old, stellar populations. Five CHVCs of our sample have been observed so far down to I=24. We pointed the VLT towards the highest HI column density regions, as determined in Effelsberg radio data. In an alternate approach, we searched 2MASS public data towards those …
We are carrying out a survey of magnetic fields in Ap stars in open clusters in order to obtain the first sample of magnetic upper main sequence stars with precisely known ages. These data will constrain theories of field evolution in these stars. Using the new spectropolarimeter ESPaDOnS at CFHT, we have obtained 44 measurements of the mean longitudinal fields of 23 B6 - A2 stars that have been identified as possible Ap stars and that are possible members of open clusters, with a median uncertainty of about 45 G. Of these stars, 10 have definite field detections. Nine stars of our sample are …
We present stationary models of protostellar population III (Pop III, for short) accretion discs, compare them to Pop I discs, and investigate the influence of the different chemical compositions on the occurence of gravitational, thermal and thermal-viscous instabilities in the discs. In particular in the cooler regions, we find major differences between Pop III and Pop I discs, both in the structure and stability behaviour. This is mainly due to the absence of most molecules and dust in Pop III, which are very efficient absorbers in Pop I discs.
Using a reionization model simultaneously accounting for a number of experimental data sets, we investigate the nature and properties of reionization sources. Such model predicts that hydrogen reionization starts at z \approx 15, is initially driven by metal-free (PopIII) stars, and is 90% complete by z \approx 8. We find that a fraction f_γ>80% of the ionizing power at z > 7 comes from haloes of mass M<10^9 M_sun predominantly harbouring PopIII stars; a turnover to a PopII-dominated phase occurs shortly after, with this population, residing in M>10^9 M_sun haloes, yielding f_γ\approx 60% at z…
I discuss the ongoing search for stars of the Milky Way which have been referred to as members of Population III. Following a discussion of possible definitions for these stars, I consider the reasons why astronomers have undertaken this search, and list some of the numerous astrophysical uses of the extremely metal-poor stars found along the way. I then review survey techniques which have been used in the past, and provide an update on plans for future investigations. Finally, the question of when one might consider the search for Population III Finished is addressed.
Detection of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) from redshifts z > 7 would open a new window into the earliest epoch of cosmic star formation. We construct separate star formation histories at high redshifts for normal (Pop I and II) stars, and for predominantly massive (Pop III) stars. Based on these separate histories, we predict the GRB redshift distribution to be observed by the {\it Swift} mission. Regardless of whether Pop III progenitors are able to trigger GRBs, we find that a fraction 10% of all bursts detected by {\it Swift} will originate at z > 5. This baseline contribution is due to Pop I/II…
We discuss the cosmological significance of the transition from the Pop III to Pop II mode of star formation in the early universe, and when and how it may occur in primordial galaxies. Observations that could detect this transition include those of element abundances in metal-poor Galactic halo stars, and of the helium reionization and associated heating of the intergalactic medium. We suggest that gamma-ray bursts may be a better probe of the end of the first-stars epoch than of Pop III stars.
The transition from Population III to Population II stars is determined by the presence of a sufficient amount of metals, in particular, oxygen and carbon. The vastly different yields of these relevant metals between different initial stellar mass functions would then cause such a transition to occur at different times. We show that the transition from Pop III to Pop II stars is likely to occur before the universe can be reionized, if the IMF is entirely very massive stars (M > 140 M_sun). A factor of about 10 more ionizing photons would be produced in the case with normal top-heavy IMF (e.g.,…
We calculate evolution and nucleosynthesis in massive Pop III stars with M = 13 ~ 270Msun, and compare the results with abundances of very metal-poor halo stars. The observed abundances can be explained by the energetic core-collapse supernovae with M < ~ 130Msun (``hypernovae'') but not by pair-instability supernovae (PISNe) with M ~ 140-270 Msun. This result constrain the IMF for the Pop III and very metal-poor Pop II stars.
We estimate the gravitational wave (GW) background from Population III (Pop III) stars using the results from our hydrodynamic simulations (Suwa et al. 2007). We calculate gravitational waveforms from matter motions and anisotropic neutrino emissions for single Pop III stars. We find that the GW amplitudes from matter motions are dominant until just after bounce, but those from neutrinos dominate later on at frequencies below $\sim 10$ Hz in the GW spectrum. Computing the overall signal produced by the ensemble of such Pop III stars, we find that the resultant density parameter of the GW backg…
The presence (or absence) of CNO elements in the primordial gas determines different behaviours in population III stars formation and evolution: we therefore present an analysis of the main channels for the synthesis of these elements in BBN in order to understand, within a reliable interval, their abundance in the primordial material.
In this paper we briefly review some of the most recent developments concerning the formation of the first luminous objects in the universe, to which we refer to as Pop III objects, and their observable effects. In particular, we try to critically discuss the possible connection between them and dwarf spheroidal galaxies. We come to the conclusion that, if the properties of Pop IIIs are correctly predicted by hierarchical cosmological models, their identification with present day dwarf galaxies presents several difficulties.
We investigate the stability of black hole accretion disks in a primordial environment (POP III disks for short), by solving the vertical structure of optically thick disks, including convective energy transport, and by employing a one-zone model for optically thin isothermal disks. Because of the absence of metals in POP III disks, we find significant differences in stability associated with ionization between POP III disks and the disks of solar metallicity. An unstable branch in S-shaped equilibrium curves on the Mdot-Sigma (mass accretion rate - surface density) plane extends to a larger s…
We review recent 3D cosmological hydrodynamic simulations of primordial star formation from cosmological initial conditions (Pop III.1) and from initial conditions that have been altered by radiative feedback from stellar sources (Pop III.2). We concentrate on simulations that resolve the formation of the gravitationally unstable cloud cores in mini-halos over the mass range $10^5 < M/\Msun < 10^7 $ and follow their evolution to densities of at least $10^{10} \cmm3$ and length scales of $<10^{-2}$ pc such that accretion rates can be estimated. The advent of ensembles of such simulations explor…
We briefly review the motivations for studying the formation of the first ``Population III'' stars and present recent results from our numerical simulations in this area. We discuss the new questions raised as a result of the simulations presented by us and others at this meeting.
We examine the significance of the first metal-free stars (Pop III) for the cosmological reionization of HI and HeII. These stars have unusually hard spectra, with the integrated ionizing photon rates from a Pop III stellar cluster for HI and HeII being 1.6 and $10^5$ times stronger respectively than those from a Pop II cluster. For the currently favored cosmology, we find that Pop III stars alone can reionize HI and HeII at redshifts, $z$ of about 9 (4.7) and 5.1 (0.7) for continuous (instantaneous) modes of star formation. More realistic scenarios involving combinations of Pop III and Pop II…
We review some of the possible observable effects (reionization, feedback on galaxy formation, supernovae and metal enrichment) of the first collapsed, luminous (Pop III) objects in the universe. We show that supernovae in these objects should be considerably magnified by the intervening cosmological matter distribution; the implications of this process are briefly discussed, anticipating some of the results of Marri & Ferrara (1998).
We review the recent measurements on the cosmic infrared background (CIB) and their implications for the physics of the first stars era, including Population III. The recently obtained CIB results range from the direct measurements of CIB fluctuations from distant sources using deep Spitzer data to strong upper limits on the near-IR CIB from blazar spectra. This allows to compare the Population III models with the CIB data to gain direct insight into the era of the first stars and the formation and evolution of Population III and the microphysics of the feedback processes in the first halos of…
We study the evolution of first star (Population III) binaries. Under specific conditions, these stars may produce high redshift gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). We demonstrate that the occurrence rate of GRBs does not depend sensitively on evolutionary parameters in the population synthesis models. We show that the first binaries may form a very small group (< 1%) of fast rotating stars through binary tidal interactions that make GRBs. This finding is contrary to the Bromm & Loeb assumption that all stars in close Population III binaries will be spun up by tides and produce a GRB. We find that there …
Populations of relativistic electrons in clusters of galaxies should imprint a characteristic spectral distortion signature on the Cosmic Microwave Background photons - the relativistic Sunyaev-Zeldovich (SZ) effect. We investigate how sensitive PLANCK and successor experiments will be in detecting or constraining the total optical depth tau of relativistic electrons. We find an expected sensitivity of PLANCK of sigma_tau ~ 2 10^-5 for an individual cluster, which is too insensitive to detect even optimistic scenarios, which predict tau ~ 10^-6 to 10^-7. However, by stacking the PLANCK-signal …
The diverse isotopic and elemental signatures produced in different nucleosynthetic sites are passed on to successive generations of stars. By tracing these chemical signatures back through the stellar populations of the Galaxy, it is possible to unravel its nucleosynthetic history and even to study stars which are now extinct. This review considers recent applications of "stellar genetics" to examine the earliest episodes of nucleosynthesis in the Universe, in Population III stars and the Big Bang.
Intracluster medium (ICM) abundances are higher than expected assuming enrichment by supernovae with progenitors belonging to the simple stellar population (SSP) observed in cluster galaxies, if stars formed with a standard initial mass function (IMF). Moreover, new results on ICM oxygen abundances imply that nucleosynthesis occurred with nonstandard yields. The hypothesis that hypernovae (HN) in general, and HN associated with Population III (Pop III) stars in particular, may significantly contribute to ICM enrichment is presented and evaluated. The observed abundance anomalies can be explain…
A PopIII/Pop II transition from massive to normal stars is predicted to occur when the metallicity of the star forming gas crosses the critical range Z_cr = 10^(-5 +/- 1) Z_sun. To investigate the cosmic implications of such process we use numerical simulations which follow the evolution, metal enrichment and energy deposition of both Pop III and Pop II stars. We find that: (i) due to inefficient heavy element transport by outflows and slow "genetic" transmission during hierarchical growth, large fluctuations around the average metallicity arise; as a result Pop III star formation continues do…
Following the successful mapping of the last scattering surface by WMAP and balloon experiments, the epoch of the first stars, when Population III stars formed, is emerging as the next cosmological frontier. It is not clear what these stars' properties were, when they formed or how long their era lasted before leading to the stars and galaxies we see today. We show that these questions can be answered with the current and future measurements of the near-IR cosmic infrared background (CIB). Theoretical arguments suggest that Population III stars were very massive and short-lived stars that form…
Population-III (Pop-III) starformation (SF) is thought to be quenched when the metallicity of the star-forming gas reaches a critical level. At high z, when the general intergalactic medium (IGM) was enriched with metals, the fraction of primordial gas already collapsed in minihalos was significantly larger than the fraction of primordial gas that had already been involved in Pop-III SF. We argue that this minihalo gas remained largely in a metal-free state, until these minihalos merged into large systems and formed stars. As a result, the era of Pop-III SF was significantly prolonged, leading…
In an earlier paper (Cen 2003) we pointed out the strong likelihood for the universal reionization to occur twice, giving rise to a larger Thomson optical depth. Here we perform a more focused analysis of the Thomson optical depth in light of the WMAP observations. While the current uncertainties on the observed Thomson optical depth are still relatively large, with tau_e=0.17+-0.04 (68%) (Kogut et al 2003), important implications on Pop III star formation processes at high redshift can already be inferred. We are able to draw four conclusions: (1) in the absence of a top-heavy initial stellar…
We make a critical assessment of models that attribute the recently detected near-infrared background ``excess'' (NIRBE) to the redshifted light from Population III objects. To supply the required 25 keV/baryon at redshift 9, Pop III massive stars must form with an efficiency exceeding 30% in all ``minihalos'' with virial temperatures above a few hundred kelvins: to avoid excessive metal pollution, most of the baryons once in Pop III stars must end up in intermediate-mass black holes (IMBHs). Gas accretion onto such IMBHs must either be inhibited or lead to early miniquasars with steep UV/X-ra…
We study the formation of molecular hydrogen in cooling gas behind shocks produced during the blow-away process thought to occur in the first collapsed, luminous (Pop III) objects in the early universe. We find that for a wide range of physical parameters the $H_2$ fraction is $f \approx 6 \times 10^{-3}$. The $H_2$ mass produced in such explosions can exceed the amount of relic $H_2$ destroyed inside the photodissociation region surrounding a given Pop III. We conclude that these first objects, differently from the suggestion of Haiman et al 1997, might have a net positive feedback on subsequ…
We present preliminary results of an incoming theoretical work concerning the integrated properties of the Population III clusters of stars. On the basis of synthetic Color-Magnitude Diagrams, we provide a grid of optical and near-IR colors of Simple Stellar Populations with very low metallicity (Z=10$^{-10}$ and Z=10$^{-6}$) and age which spans from 10 Myr to 15 Gyr. A comparison with higher metallicities up to 0.006 is also shown, disclosing sizable differences in the CMD morphology, integrated colors and Spectral Energy Distribution (SED).
The first stars hold intrinsic interest for their uniqueness and for their potential importance to galaxy formation, chemical enrichment, and feedback on the intergalactic medium (IGM). The metal-free composition of the first stars restricts the stellar energy source to proton-proton burning rather than the more efficient CNO cycle. Consequently they are hotter, smaller, and have harder spectra than their present-day counterparts of finite metallicity. We present new results from a continuing study of metal-free stars from a cosmological point of view. We have calculated evolving spectra of Po…
We study the expected diffuse cosmic neutrino flux produced by Population III (PopIII) stars during their nuclear burning phases as well as from their final stages of evolution (core collapse). Assuming a fraction f_III=10^(-3) of all baryons forms PopIII stars, our flux estimate is comparable to the diffuse neutrino flux produced by the ordinary stars and by the ordinary core-collapse supernovae in the universe, i.e. of order 1-10 cm^(-2) s^(-1). Due to the large cosmic redshift, however, the typical energies are in the MeV and sub-MeV range where the solar and geophysical neutrino fluxes are…
