In the Letter [1] (also [2]) there is a claim that the generalised second law of thermodynamics (entropy increase) for black holes provides some limits on the rate of variation of the fundamental constants of nature (electric charge e, speed of light c, etc.). We have come to a different conclusion. The results in [1,2] are based on assumption that mass of a black hole does not change without radiation and accreation. We present arguments showing that this assumption is incorrect and give an estimate of the black hole mass variation due to alpha=e^2/\hbar c variation using entropy (and quantum energy level) conservation in an adiabatic process. No model-independent limits on the variation of the fundamental constants are derived from the second law of thermodynamics.
Note on fundamental physics tests from black hole imaging: Comment on "Hunting for extra dimensions in the shadow of Sagittarius A$^*$"
在过去几年中,有几项工作讨论了使用甚长基线干涉测量视界尺度黑洞(BH)图像测试基础物理的可能性,例如事件视界望远镜(EHT)拍摄的M87 $^*$和人马座A $^*$(Sgr A $^*$)图像,使用BH阴影的尺寸$r_{\rm sh}$和圆度偏差$Δ\mathcal{C}$。对于Sgr A $^*$的EHT图像,由于2017年观测的干涉测量覆盖范围稀疏,以及与M87 $^*$相比,Sgr A $^*$的变化时间尺度较短,因此无法获得对$Δ\mathcal{C}$的限制。关于这一点,我们评论的结果,最近的预印本,声称已得出新的限制额外的维度使用偏离圆的Sgr A $^*$的阴影。后者被引用为$\lesssim 10\%$,与M87 $^*$一样,基于两个阴影的“相似性”:然而,这是一个不正确的假设,使随后的结果无效。因此,在不久的将来,从Sgr A $^*$的图像中对基础物理进行的最简单的测试将主要依赖于$r_{\rm sh}$,而诸如光子环和方位角推移等其他可观测量应该很快就会出现,并允许进行新的测试。
Black Hole Constraints on Varying Fundamental Constants
在这里,我们应用广义热力学第二定律,并推导出基本常数变化的上限。在当前的宇宙微波背景中,黑洞吸积和发射所允许的电子电荷的最大变化对应于精细结构常数的变化((Δ α)/α)~ 2 x 10^-23/秒。这个数值与韦伯等人使用遥远类星体光谱中的吸收线测量的变化相匹配,并表明变化机制可能是电子和宇宙光子背景之间的耦合。