arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 0802.0509stat.AP
收藏

估计体重增加对死亡率影响的因果模型

Causal Models for Estimating the Effects of Weight Gain on Mortality

James Robins

摘要:

假设,与事实相反,在1950年,我们对18岁的非吸烟美国男性进行了严格的强制性饮食,以保证没有人的体重超过18岁时确定的基线体重。这些18岁儿童的反事实死亡率与2007年观察到的实际死亡率相比如何?我们详细描述了如何通过将g-估计应用于一个新的结构嵌套模型,从类似于存储在大型HMO电子病历中的纵向流行病学数据中估计这种反事实的对比。我们的分析方法与任何替代方法的不同之处在于,在模型错误指定的约束下,它可以成功地调整(i)测量的时变混杂因素,如运动,高血压和糖尿病,它们同时是从体重增加到死亡的因果路径上的中间变量和未来体重增加的决定因素,(ii)未确诊的临床前疾病造成的未测量的混杂(即反向因果关系),可导致体重增加不良和过早死亡[如果可以为受试者可能遭受严重到足以影响其体重而疾病没有变得临床明显的亚临床疾病的最大时间长度指定上限],和(iii)存在特定的可识别亚组,如患有严重肾脏、肝脏、肺部和/或心脏疾病的亚组,这些亚组中存在严重的不可测量的预后因素,以致于任何直接分析调整的尝试都是无用的。

英文摘要:

Suppose, contrary to fact, in 1950, we had put the cohort of 18 year old non-smoking American men on a stringent mandatory diet that guaranteed that no one would ever weigh more than their baseline weight established at age 18. How would the counter-factual mortality of these 18 year olds have compared to their actual observed mortality through 2007? We describe in detail how this counterfactual contrast could be estimated from longitudinal epidemiologic data similiar to that stored in the electronic medical records of a large HMO by applying g-estimation to a novel structural nested model. Our analytic approach differs from any alternative approach in that in that, in the abscence of model misspecification, it can successfully adjust for (i) measured time-varying confounders such as exercise, hypertension and diabetes that are simultaneously intermediate variables on the causal pathway from weight gain to death and determinants of future weight gain, (ii) unmeasured confounding by undiagnosed preclinical disease (i.e reverse causation) that can cause both poor weight gain and premature mortality [provided an upper bound can be specified for the maximum length of time a subject may suffer from a subclinical illness severe enough to affect his weight without the illness becomes clinically manifest], and (iii) the prescence of particular identifiable subgroups, such as those suffering from serious renal, liver, pulmonary, and/or cardiac disease, in whom confounding by unmeasured prognostic factors so severe as to render useless any attempt at direct analytic adjustment.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑