We examine the performance of several molecular simulation techniques aimed at evaluation of the surface tension through its thermodynamic definition. For all methods explored, the surface tension is calculated by approximating the change in Helmholtz free energy associated with a change in interfacial area through simulation of a liquid slab at constant particle number, volume, and temperature. The methods explored fall within three general classes: free-energy perturbation, the Bennett acceptance-ratio scheme, and the expanded ensemble technique. Calculations are performed for both the truncated Lennard-Jones and square-well fluids at select temperatures spaced along their respective liquid-vapor saturation lines. Overall, we find that Bennett and expanded ensemble approaches provide the best combination of accuracy and precision. All of the methods, when applied using sufficiently small area perturbation, generate equivalent results for the Lennard-Jones fluid. However, single-stage free-energy-perturbation methods and the closely related test-area technique recently introduced by Gloor et al. [J. Chem. Phys. 123, 134703 (2005)], generate surface tension values for the square-well fluid that are not consistent with those obtained from the more robust expanded ensemble and Bennett approaches, regardless of the size of the area perturbation. Single-stage perturbation methods fail also for the Lennard-Jones system when applied using large area perturbations. Here an analysis of phase-space overlap produces a quantitative explanation of the observed inaccuracy, and shows that the satisfactory results obtained in these cases from the test-area method arise from a cancellation of errors that cannot be expected in general.
我们使用计算机模拟和一个简单的自由能模型来研究双层膜的负(压缩)机械张力的应用程序的响应。这种张力使巨囊泡的长波长波动模式不稳定,但当考虑小膜和囊泡时,它可以持续。我们的负张力模拟结果揭示了两个制度-(i)一个弱的负张力制度,其特征在于拉伸为主的弹性,和(ii)一个强的负张力制度,其特征在于弯曲为主的弹性行为。这类似于在巨大单层囊泡(GUV)中的经典Evans和Rawicz微量移液管抽吸实验的发现[Phys,Rev. Lett. { \bf 64},2094(1990)]。然而,在GUV中,两种弹性状态之间的交叉发生在小的正表面张力下,而在较小的膜中,它发生在中等的负张力下。关于小膜对负表面张力的响应的另一个有趣的观察与机械张力和波动张力之间的关系有关,对于非负值,机械张力和波动张力彼此相等。当张力减小到负值时,波动张力$γ$在小的负张力区域中比$τ$下降得稍微快一些,然后在大的负张力下饱和(并且变得大于$τ$)。弯曲模量呈现“相反”的趋势。它几乎保持不变,在拉伸为主的弹性制度,并减少在弯曲为主的制度。热高度波动和投影面积变化的振幅在机械不稳定性开始时发散。