说明:考虑Biodiversity周期的情况:重新检验化石记录中周期性的证据,Lieberman和Melott著,arXiv预印本0704.2896
Note on: Considering the Case for Biodiversity Cycles: Reexamining the Evidence for Periodicity in the Fossil Record, by Lieberman and Melott, arXiv preprint 0704.2896
摘要:
Lieberman和Melott在我发表的论文上建立了他们最近的arXiv预印本0704.2896,以及Lieberman的同事Cornette随后的评论。但是,如果这个小组等待科内特的评论实际上出现在印刷与预期的答复,他们会了解到,他的评论暴露科内特的混乱,可能是由于期刊印刷错误的我的数字。0704.2896是没有根据的尽管收到了带有勘误表的扩展回复,这些作者仍然没有认识到,他们错误地认为必须对古生物学记录进行去趋势化,这是一种武断的而不是普遍的操作。
英文摘要:
Lieberman and Melott built their recent arXiv preprint 0704.2896 on my published paper and (a preprint of) a subsequent comment by Liebermans associate Cornette. But had this group waited for the Cornette comment to actually appear in print together with the expected Reply, they would have learned that his comment exposes Cornettes confusion that likely was due to journal misprint of my figure. Thus 0704.2896 is baseless. Despite receiving the extended Reply with Errata, these authors still fail to recognize that detrending of paleontological records-which they erroneously promote as a must-is an arbitrary rather than a universal operation.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。