arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv physics/0502141physics.chem-ph
收藏

朗之万方程的起源和均方位移的计算:让我们把记录弄清楚

The origin of the Langevin equation and the calculation of the mean squared displacement: Let's set the record straight

K. Razi Naqvi

摘要:

奥恩斯坦和他的合著者以方程$mdv/dt =-ζv+X$为出发点,建立了布朗运动的动力学理论,他们通常以爱因斯坦一人或爱因斯坦和朗之万的名字命名方程;此外,奥恩斯坦是第一个从这个方程中得出$\bar{Δ^2}$的正确表达式的人,布朗粒子所覆盖的均方距离,归功于哈斯-洛伦兹,而不是朗之万,用于寻找$\bar{Δ^2}$的平稳极限。只要看一眼爱因斯坦1907年发表的题为"关于布朗运动的理论评论“的论文,就足以使人相信,把上述方程的{ \it概念}(现在被普遍称为朗之万方程)归功于爱因斯坦并不是不公平的。朗之万在他1908年的文章中公开宣称的目标是通过一种“无限简单”的途径恢复爱因斯坦1905年的扩散系数表达式,但仔细阅读朗之万的论文可以发现--取决于人们如何解释他对上述方程中出现的随机力$X$的统计行为的描述--他的分析充其量是不完整的,最坏的情况也不过是同义反复由于教科书的帐户是基于解释,使证明谬误,替代推导,这是改编的德哈斯-洛伦兹和奥恩斯坦,在这里提出。一些被忽视的方面的内容奥恩斯坦的早期文件的布朗运动也带来了光。

英文摘要:

Ornstein and his coauthors, who constructed a dynamical theory of Brownian motion, taking the equation $mdv/dt =-ζv+X$ as their starting point, usually named the equation after Einstein alone or after both Einstein and Langevin; furthermore, Ornstein, who was the first to extract from this equation the correct expression for $\bar{Δ^2}$, the mean-squared distance covered by a Brownian particle, credited de Haas-Lorentz, rather than Langevin, for finding the stationary limit of $\bar{Δ^2}$. A glance at Einstein's 1907 paper, titled ``Theoretical remarks on Brownian motion'', should suffice to convince one that it is not unfair to attribute the {\it conception} of the above equation, now universally known as the Langevin equation, to Einstein. Langevin's avowed aim in his 1908 article was to recover, through a route that was `infinitely more simple', Einstein's 1905 expression for the diffusion coefficient, but a careful reading of Langevin's paper shows that--depending on how one interprets his description of the statistical behavior of the random force $X$ appearing in the above equation--his analysis is at best incomplete, and at worst a mere tautology. Since textbook accounts are based on the interpretation that renders the proof fallacious, alternative derivations, which are adaptations of those given by de Haas-Lorentz and Ornstein, are presented here. Some neglected aspects of the contents of Ornstein's early papers on Brownian motion are also brought to light.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑